preview

Miceexcisional Cutaneou Summary

Decent Essays
Rafail et al. examine the role effects of the complement system, a division of the immune system, on the wound healing process in miceexcisional cutaneou. The study focused focuses on the third (C3) and fifth (C5) main components of the complement system believed to mediate the inflammatory responsetwo., C3 and C , The experimenters induceThe C3-/- mice, lacking the third component of the complement system, exhibited smaller wound surface areas compared to C3 +/+ mice. The authors suggest the decreased inflammatory response and the increased presence of mast cells and α-SMA+ vessels indicate the development of new vasculature and account for the improved wound healing rates in C3-/- mice. Mice lacking C5 similarly exhibited increased…show more content…
The differential healing rates among three mice in a group may result from individual variation within each mouse. For example, the immune system of one mouse, that accounts for 2 data points, may promote faster healing for an unexamined reason. With a single mouse’s wounds constituting one-third of the data, individual variability easily obscures the true cause for accelerated healing and prevents generalization of the results to conclude the differences are due to C3 inhibition.
In addition to the concerns regarding C3 mice sample size, Rafail et al. extrapolate the mechanism of delayed wound healing in the C3 +/+ group, attributing the results to C5a signaling. The authors use data to support the difference in wound healing rates and composition between both the C3 groups and the C5 groups; however, they stretch the results to connect the C3 and C5 components with an unexamined mechanism. The study never explores C3 mediation by C5a, yet suggests C5a as a mediator along the C3 pathway. Data limit the logical conclusions that follow from a study; without supporting evidence, a mechanism to describe C5a as a mediator in the C3 pathway is a conjecture.
Despite the challenges with sample size ambiguity and extrapolation of a C5a mediation mechanism, the study methodically demonstrates the effects of the C3 component through reconstitution studies. After initial results suggested C3 deficiency improves wound healing, reconstitution of C3-/- mice with C3
    Get Access