preview

Milkweed Effect

Good Essays

Out of the journal articles I used I found “Milkweed loss in agricultural fields because of herbicide use: effect on the monarch butterfly population,” by John M. Pleasants and Karen S. Oberhausen to be the best fit for my project. Their article is divided into nine sections which are as follows: Abstract, Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion, Acknowledgements, Author contributions, Competing financial interests, and References. Pleasants' and Oberhausen’s abstract is divided further into four parts, the first of which states, “The size of the Mexican overwintering population of monarch butterflies has decreased over the last decade,” (10). That same point continues to discuss the reasons for the monarch population decrease, including …show more content…

It then discusses the decreasing in Mexican overwintering populations and the decreases of milkweed. In the introduction they link the increasing use of “glyphosate herbicide increased in conjunction with the increased adoption of glyphosate-tolerant corn and soybeans,” (10) to the decreasing amounts of milkweed. They then present one of the problems which faced they was how to monitor the population of monarch butterflies. They show the advantages and disadvantages of two different methods already being used. These are as follows: tagging adult monarchs and counting migrating monarchs in areas where they become concentrated. However, these techniques are not being used to count monarchs in the Midwest so they decided to determine the destiny of monarch eggs on milkweed in a variety of different patches. They then used the amount of eggs per plant to determine “the effect of milkweed resource limitation on monarch production,” …show more content…

They discuss the variety of sources used to collect data and where they gathered data from in both Non-agricultural habitats and Agricultural habitats. They then present the following: “ Estimates of the amount of milkweed in non-agricultural habitats, agricultural fields and total milkweeds in Iowa from 1999 to 2010,” (10) as a table. They then point out their sources for the data they used on land use. They acknowledge that their land use data were published in 2006 and is therefore somewhat out of date, however, they anticipate that the numbers were still similar when they published their paper. Next, they estimate the monarch use of non-agricultural milkweed and provide data on the “monarch use of milkweeds in agricultural fields,” (10). Their data points to the conclusion that monarchs use agricultural milkweed at a greater frequency than non-agricultural milkweed. In the final subsection of the methods section Pleasants and Oberhausen estimate the potential monarch

Get Access