preview

Motherhood In Herland

Decent Essays

erland incorporates more fundamentals of Berry’s authentic economy through the sacred practice of motherhood that the Herlandians articulate throughout the story. Berry asserts that an authentic economy incorporates economic virtues of “honesty, thrift, care, good work, generosity, and imagination, from which we have compassion” (Berry 475). These values are essential in having a sustainable economy. Herland exemplifies these compassionate and caring values through their motherhood practices. The ability of the Herland women to conceive asexually leads them to see motherhood as the central aspect of their beings which is their greatest duty and their greatest honor. Mothership is also used as a form of social organization. Each woman in Herland …show more content…

The men represent our flawed society while the Herland society represents the authentic economy Berry advocates. For example, any society in which children are not the highest priority is immoral to the women of Herland, and this perspective makes the men unwilling to admit how often children are neglected in their “civilized” world. The women are appalled when Van mentions abortion. Somel’s very repudiating reaction to the subject of abortion shows that our society is the strange one when compared to Herland’s. In Herland, Gilman clearly expresses the significant differences in the way things are done in Herland and the way our society does things. At first, these contrasts seem basic; incidental differences any two cultures would have. As the men become more familiar with Herland, however, it shows how insufficient and inferior our society really is in comparison to Herland’s. One case is the contrast in the matter of the naturalization of animals. Herland’s cats are smart, healthy, and beautiful. They have been what they call “systematically bred” for good behavior, chasing rodents only and leaving birds unharmed. Somel and Zava are shocked and disgusted to hear about the filthiness and disease correlated with dogs in the outer world and question why such a situation is tolerated. Eventually, after increasingly distinct comparisons, Van and his friends begin to ponder why their society does tolerate such things. One of the most surprising examples of the contrast between Herland’s society and outside societies is the way the women calmly embrace the population controls required to sustain the population on their isolated plain. Although many of the women would prefer to have multiple children, they are limited to just one, and some are forbidden to reproduce at all because their society “makes it their first business to train out, to breed out, when possible, the lowest

Get Access