preview

Essay on Pardoner's Manipulation of Audience

Decent Essays

Pardoner's Manipulation of Audience

The Pardoner has had a graduate education in the rhetoric of confession. Chaucer might

intend it to be merely cutely ironic that this confessor confesses -- as in "isn't that a turning of the tables, la!" On the other hand, it may well be that the Pardoner is practicing his rhetorical prowess on the other pilgrims, and on us, with the extreme skill of a cynical and perceptive man who's heard every villainy and mastered every deception. His intention, in his "confession" to the pilgrims, is obviously not to manipulate them into pity, forgiveness and acceptance, any more than it is to get them to actually pay to touch his "holy relics"; it is a confession, …show more content…

His keen insight into human depravity is what makes him such a brilliant con. He plays on the most deep-seated insecurities of his flock when he describes the magical powers of his relics. They will cure sick livestock (livestock being the most valuable possession of the average listener, not to mention shepherds); they will prosper crops (for all the farmers in the audience). That covers the men! To the women, he offers the fantastic promise that his relics will cure their husbands of their jealousy and suspicion. This is doubly clever, in light of the Wife of Bath's tale, because it picks up on her ideal of women empowered to cheat on doting, trusting, forgiving husbands.

'Let maken with this water his potage,

And never shal he more his wyf mistriste,

Though he the sooth of hir defaute wiste;

Al had she taken preestes two or three.'

It's trebly clever, actually, because the last line can be read both as sexual solicitations to the women in his flock, as well as an insult to the three priests present on the pilgrimage.

His next con is even more wickedly clever; he demonstrates how he subtly manipulates

his flock into coming forward and making offerings to his relics in order to avoid suspicion that they have committed some horrible sin.

'If any wight be in this chirche now,

That hath doon sinne horrible,

Get Access