Is Pearl Harbor Historically Accurate
Although Michael Bay’s movie Pearl Harbor is very well made it has more historically inaccurate parts than accurate parts. Michael Bay even says that it's a movie to give people the feeling of Pearl Harbor not the real facts of it.
The movie is based on two real pilots from the real Pearl Harbor named George Welch and Kenneth Taylor. Taylor was not told that there was going to be a new film so when he watched it he said “... a piece of trash..over-sensationalized and distorted”. (Wikipedia) The whole three-hour movie is based on a love story/ triangle that never happened with only a 40-minute fight scene. This movie is supposed to be based on the real events that happened in Pearl Harbor so there should
…show more content…
(Hollywood) This is saying something because if they can not get small facts like that right how could they get big facts right. Another small thing was that when FDR went to speak at the press conference he would not have come up in his wheelchair because he did not want people to know that he was unable to walk, and the scene when he stood up from his chair most likely did not happen because he always wanted to hide his disability.
Admiral Nimitz that was seen finding out about the bombing on the golf course was not on the golf course in the real bombing. The golf game was planned but never actually happened. He found out about the attack on his way there and never made it. (Hollywood) In the movie, they make him look like he has no idea that an attack could happen on Pearl Harbor but in the real events he has speculation of an attack. President Roosevelt never had to convince Admiral Nimitz to plan an attack on Japan after the Pearl Harbor attack they were always in complete
…show more content…
(Hollywood) None of the Pilots were killed during this raid and the movie shows that some were killed. The technology that the pilots had in their aircraft is also inaccurate because the technology seen in the aircraft from the movie is 21st-century technology and it was the 1940s. (Walsh) There was a part in the movie where the people in that command pot could hear everything going on from another country and that would not have been
First, the main characters in the book were Danny, Danny's mom, Aki, aki's mom, and Mack but the research we have said they did not exist. Some people who were there during the attack were admiral husband Kimmel, General Walter C. Short, and president Franklin Delano Roosevelt. Second, the planes in the attack were told not to hurt people or the hospitals. The plains were told to only attack ships. The attack was planned by Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto, who did not want to go to war with the us. Third, In the book they talked about the air force place Hickam Air Force base which research told us it did exist and is still in use today. All in all, the book I survived the bombing of Pearl Harbor was correct on some
The main focus on this essay is “Why Did Japan Attack Pearl Harbor?”. On a normal Sunday morning when the American navy units were busy doing their normal routine work, the Japanese navy planned a surprise attack that stunned the world. This attack was so unpredictable that the entire American navy went in deep shock. Very few of them realized the need to manage and control their position to save the naval power. All the staff and ships that were present at the Pearl Harbor suffered massive loss. Just a couple of hours of bombing gave the Pearl Harbor, a battlefield view with fire and smoke emerging from every corner. The attack left American navy at a loss of 2400 of her best men as well as 21 ships that were either sunk or completely demolished.
December 7, 1941: Attacks on Pearl Harbor: Around November 25, the US intercepted a message of an imminent attack on US soil. In addition, Japan started to move its navy towards Hawaii. Washington’s response to this was a warning to Hawaii, indicating the anticipated attack. However, on December 7, 1941, a fleet on Japanese bombers approached Pearl Harbor with the intent to bomb the navy port. US navy ships were left defenseless as the Japanese torpedoes starting to sink them. Within two hours, US lost eight battleships, two cruisers, and more than a hundred planes. About two thousand soldiers died and one thousand were injured. As a result of this attack, President Roosevelt addressed the Congress, asking for the declaration of war. On
The passing of the Lend-Lease Act gave the United States permission to fund nations such as Britain and France, with guns, other arms. It allowed the United States get involved, while claiming neutrality.
Although the naval ships in Hawaii went unprotected, commercial ships did not. On November 25th shipping via the North Pacific was banned. The South Pacific was the now the only transpacific route approved for U.S and Allied ships to use. This is highly suspicious given the Japanese fleet was said to have set sail toward Hawaii the same day this policy was ordered. Some argue that F.D.R did this to protect commercial ships from becoming collateral damage to the Japanese fleet. Others said he made this call to ensure that the Japanese fleet went undetected and that the attack on Pearl Harbor would be successful. Whichever theory one chooses to believe as to why F.D.R made this call, it is apparent that the U.S indeed was at least aware of an attack on the Pacific, if not the precise location and that they took certain measures to protect commercial ships but not naval ones (Pearl Harbor: Hawaii).
Infamy is the story focusing not on the actual event of Pearl Harbor, but the aftermath.
Some of these aircraft were indeed B-17’s, B-18’s, A-20’s, and many other kinds, but many of these aircraft that were there at the time of the attack were either damaged or destroyed. As I have said, this book was accurate in many ways, another way this book was accurate was because it said Mr. Sudo was arrested after the attack. The book and research said that after the attack; America decided to force any Japanese people living in America to move back to Japan or move to heavily guarded camps; whilst some people moved; others were arrested. Also, the book said that during the attack a Japanese plane fired bullets at Danny. It also said the pilot was young, back then they wanted young adults to serve in the war at hand.
An event that shook the nation, will not bring it to its knees. Japan bombed Pearl Harbor, Hawaii and afterward, the U.S. entered the war. What reason did the Japanese have to bomb Pearl Harbor? Japan attacked Pearl Harbor because they saw the U.S. as a threat because they cut off their reasons, threatened them by moving military forces, and they stand in the way of Japan’s new order.
The attack on Pearl Harbor was the product of Japanese anger at the United States and President Roosevelt should have taken immediate action to prevent it.
Although the convoy system seemed effective in action, as it was, you have to ask yourself if it was effective in the long run. We likely wouldn't have been pulled into the war if we hadn't partook in the escorting of merchant ships.
To start off, pearl harbor is a failure because ships were damaged, sunken, and destroyed. 1,177 crewmen killed were apart of the U.S navy band unit and also pearl harbor claimed the lives of 2,400 citizens and also wounded 1,000 people. Franklin D. Roosevelt described pearl harbor as "date which we live in infamy," because the naval battleship USS Arizona was hit four times by the Japanese bombers and also because 23 sets of brothers aboard the USS Arizona airline were killed. However, almost half the casualties on the battleship were on the USS Arizona and eventually the battleship sunk, after 70 years Arizona continues to spill up to 9 quarts of oil into the harbor each day. In conclusion, the overall attack on pearl harbor was intended
According to the book The Pearl Harbor Myth: Rethinking the Unthinkable, the author says the President Roosevelt surprised his advisers twelve days before the attack, by saying the war on Japan was about to begin. So, if Roosevelt knew, why didn’t keep the caution in military bases or the whole country. It was also said that Henry Stimson the secretary of war, noted on his diary that President Roosevelt asked what should they do. The question was should maneuver them into the position of firing the first shot without allowing too much danger for ourselves. Many generations of scholars always disregard Stimson diary and accuse him of writing too fast, or writing about what he believed. Stimson also wrote that by long traditions, our presidents are not seen
War between Japan and the US was inevitable around the time of the attack. Everyone knew that sooner or later we would be in a conflict with The Japanese Empire for some reason or another since the 1920’s. It all started when the Japanese
The film also encompassed another story line that focused away from the actions of the attack on Pearl Harbor and gave the film more than just a Naval attack. The filmmakers had to have more to the story than the initial attack. They added the love triangle between the 3 main characters and added the child to give the story a more dramatic plot. The background of this film was added to give the viewer more clarity of what it took to be a pilot and also to add to the overall effect of the film.
Tora! Tora! Tora! is a 1970 film that displays the historical accuracy of Pearl Harbor. Pearl Harbor was a shock to the United States after the naval base at Pearl Harbor in Hawaii was attacked on December 7, 1941. The attack on Pearl Harbor by the Japanese was a spark into World War II. The attack itself took place before the actual declaration of war was made. Admiral Yamamoto’s intention was to wait thirty minutes after Japan informed the United States (U.S.) that their peace was over. This film shows the historical accuracy of both sides from both the American and Japanese points of view. Through thorough explanation of Pearl Harbor, this essay will display the historical accuracy of Tora! Tora!