preview

Persuasive Essay On The Giver

Decent Essays

Many thanks to all those who have participated in today’s debate. It is a question worth asking. It is a question that deserves answers. Should the government be deciding our families? In effect, running our lives? We, the opposition team say, firmly, no. They should not. Even in the world of The Giver, in the supposed utopia of the Community, it is clear that families should not be decided and designed by the government. First off, we see that great sacrifices, sacrifices so horrible to the point of being terrible crimes in our world, are made to achieve these so called, “perfect” families of The Giver. The most obvious of these is the release, or should I say murder, of twins. A mother gives birth to two beautiful, healthy children, and the Community, in their quest for perfect and perfect families, kills one of the two without emotion or second thought. We see this on page 150 as Jonas’s father injects an infant with some form of poison and then, in a sweet, kind voice, says “Bye-bye little guy” as he dumps the child’s body down “the same sort of chute into which trash was deposited at school.” And let’s keep in mind that all of this takes place months after the child was first taken from its mother. A mother who carried the child in her womb for nine long months only to never see him or her. This is a despicable act in itself. Therefore, the Community should not be celebrated for its creation of perfect families because of the terrible acts they commit to create them.

Get Access