A realistic objection to the proposal of opening a museum for German Culture may be the lack of interest in it. There would need to be some sort of interest in the idea and there is currently no data on if the citizens of Winona would be in favor or against the idea. One must also consider the cost and where the funding of this museum would come from. The reason that the Polish Museum of Winona exists is because a Catholic priest bought a building to specifically be used as a museum to house historical artifacts (SOURCE). Someone took action privately to make this museum a reality, something that may have to be done for this hypothetical museum. The financing of something like this would take a lot of money to keep running and private donations …show more content…
If the museum doesn’t get enough donations to keep it running it would show a possible lack of interest in it. Ultimately the whole concept of the museum would depend upon the interest for it as well as the willingness to take action to make it a reality, these two factors are the most important aspects of really anything that’s goal to preserve the history of any specific topic. Although there is much uncertainty on if a museum based around preserving German culture in Winona would be successful, The prevalence of people with German ancestry in Winona is very high and the impact of Germans on the development of city is undoubtable. Winona is a city with the population size of 27,139 and is filled with multiple different groups of people and ethnicities, the most common of these are white Europeans. Winona is around 90% Caucasian but out of the entire population of Winona, 30% identify as German when polled (SOURCE), which is the largest single percentage of any other group and the amount of people with German ancestry may be even higher due to the fact that many people identify as American or European or Northern European, which may indicate that these people may have …show more content…
One doesn’t have to look very hard to see the impact of it on the city, judging by how many Lutheran Churches there are in the city of Winona. The amount of Lutherans in Winona indicates the influence of German immigrants to Winona as Lutheranism is a faith almost exclusive to Germany, as Lutheranism came into existence during the protestant reformation and the founder of the church, Martin Luther, is credited with kicking off the protestant reformation in Europe. Another aspect of German culture still being a force in Winona today is the fact that the language is taught in schools as an elective (SOURCE?). In fact, German is fourth most common foreign language spoken in Winona (Source). The reason for German being taught in school is mostly due to not only the interest in it that students have but also because of the large amount of German ancestry that Winona contains. While other places may offer languages such as French or Japanese along with Spanish like Winona does, German is taught here specifically because of the impact of Germans and German culture on the city. In the city of Winona itself, the west end of town is often associated with being historically German while the east end was mostly Polish (Source). All of these examples of elements of German culture and the city of Winona go to show how much of an impact Germans have had on the city, as (Source for Minnesota a State guide) States “Among the earlier
The main purpose of the museum is to amaze the new generation and to show how life was like back then. There were many things I was amazed by of how people survived the passed. Nowadays people can't stand a day without internet, but back then people stay days without eating and managed to survive. This explains why the latest generation is lucky to be living in this generation. Mostly the museum purpose is to entertain the
In December 2002, the directors of 18 museums located throughout Europe and the United States issued the Declaration of the Importance and Value of Universal Museums. The declaration is an attempt, by the directors of major Western museums, to defend against demands for restitution of museum objects by defining themselves as “universal museums” which are of value to all of humanity. This document fails as a convincing defence against restitution claims for several reasons. First, it dismisses circumstances of older acquisitions without considering the ethics or legality of surrounding the acquisition. Second, while it pronounces these museums “universal,” it approaches this from a distinctly Western perspective and perpetuates colonial and imperialist ideas. Finally, it ignores important debates that are occurring between and within scholarly, professional, and activist communities.
The goal of any business is to make a profit, museums are no different. Capture hearts, attention, and pocketbooks. The museum curators must choose artifacts and things to feature in exhibits that will allure and attract guests and bring profit to the museum. The two problems facing museums success is “money and management’’ (source A, Rockefeller). The excerpt from an autobiography written by a fellow Rockefeller highlights the fiscal burden the management of a museum inflicts upon the owners. With the lack of support from trustees, who showed more support toward some “exhibitions, acquisitions, and programs.” rather than others, the Museum of Modern Arts floundered under pressure creating a endless financial cycle featuring deficits, debt,
Museums have long served a purpose as cultural staples. For every museum, big and small, careful consideration is used in selecting its contents. When securing new items for a museum, it is most important to consider public appeal, educational value, and cost-effectiveness.
What defines a memorial museum as a category of museum? While symbolizing the event and forming public perspectives on it, “the ethics in memorial museums, ethics morality and human deeds occupy the very heart of the topics on display, and correspondingly involve especially careful consideration of representation and reception” (Williams, Memorial museums, 220). Memorial mMuseums should be responsible at when choosing the objects they display, narrating the event and establishing visitors’ memories.
Every effort should be made ahead of time to identify a museum that has items and works one can easily connect to our HUM 111 class and book. Since HUM 111 covers from ancient times to the 1500s AD, it makes more sense to focus on items from that time frame. In general, museums with artistic cultural artifacts and fine arts work better than history museums.
I hope to see museums make more concerted efforts to educate the public. Too many exhibits are of the “passive, didactic looking” than like the engaging Object Stories program (Dartt, Murawski). Exhibits should seek to tell untold narratives, and programs should be places of communication and cross-cultural encounters. For too long, difficult confrontations have been avoided, both inside the museum, and by dominant communities
In Steven Lubar’s book, Inside the Lost Museum: Curating, Past and Present, the recurring idea that museums are “more than the sum of their parts” plays a critical role in the overall argument (329). Lubar notes many aspects that make up a museum, the collection, for example is an essential part of any museum, but the community, as well as the experiences of the patrons create a lasting museum experience. Additionally, Lubar aptly utilizes real-world examples, contemporary and historical, highlighting the work of individuals in museums and establishing a connection between past and current events. Central to this narrative is the example of the lost Jenks Museum. Lubar uses this museum to argue that museums of the past can educate museum goers
To me, museums serve as trains that deliver goods that are arts to people. Art can be perceived as a mean to entertains our life, reflects customs and communicates thoughts, ideas and emotions and it’s museums job that bring them closer to people. There is a huge difference when it came to seeing the artwork in person and seeing the artwork from a book or website and magazine. You will never be able to feel a piece properly when you see it in the textbook, you will never understand how the color was put together and what is the meaning behinds it, you won’t see how the lines and curves are blend together to make the painting look perfect and how strong that art can affect you in emotion. Many people nowadays don’t even bother watching the art themselves, they rather listening to what critics have to say about the works in their own perspective and can’t even make a decision themselves whether or not they should see the arts. “An ounce of image is worth a pound of performance”, in my opinion, I think we will never know what is good until we see it
The woman who I spoke to at the front desk was very kind and considerate. She was very friendly and trusting and I made me very excited to see the gallery. I was also very encouraged at how many children were present and enjoying their learning experience. I believe that the majority of archaeology’s worth comes from how the public benefits, even if it is only some joy at learning an interesting fact. Seeing children introduced to history and archaeology so young and enjoying the encounter is one that will always bring me a great amount of joy. So, although I wish adults could also benefit from this museum, I truly appreciate its ability to engage childrens’
First thing I noticed as I walked in the museum was that there were pictures on the wall of holocaust survivors that explains how they fought in their time and the struggles they had to go through. It was a long list of survivors and some of them were used to work of the museum and tell their stories about the Holocaust and how they survived. The next thing I noticed was an office, nearly full of books and a desk that had newspapers and letters all
The community centered around the museum has a large Jewish base, some of them even work at the museum too. The most profound thing at the museum, for me at
Some of these things were that special bridges were constructed above roads because Jews were not allowed to go on roads, and the extent of the experiments conducted on prisoners at concentration camps by Nazi scientists. When I first heard of these experiments I thought that surely they were pretty bad because it was the Nazis, but after watching a few videos and reading signs about the experiments, I learned of the true horrors that the victims were forced to endure by Nazi scientists. I think that a memorial museum like this one is a crucial institution so that people never forget the horrors of the holocaust so it is never repeated and to forever remember the people who suffered a great deal of pain and sorrow during and after the holocaust. After going to this museum, I wonder more about the experiments conducted on prisoners in concentration camps and how concentration camps were constructed and
There are opportunities though, and they are good opportunities. I was able to identify three that they should pay attention to and really hit hard on. In today’s economy, people aren’t wanting to spend a lot of money. The recession is making people be a lot more conscious about money. Good news, the museum is free. If marketed properly, this could be a huge way to gain new visitors. Plus, art museums have sophisticated connotations that make people feel smart when they go to them. What better way to spend the day than to go somewhere that is free and feel sophisticated? Another opportunity is that new exhibits could attract younger demographics, pending on the exhibit. This could be tricky though because they want to attract everyone, but older crowds are interested in things that younger generations aren’t. They have to be able to balance the attractions so everyone can relate to it and want to view it.
The German culture has been influenced by various factors, the most extreme one that comes to mind is: Adolf Hitler. Hitler, caused one of the biggest movements, that affected the whole world and how others view Germany and its culture. He wanted change, and violence is the most effective way to cause a transformative shift within cultures. White men, in the past, and even today, have the most powerful voice within the world (besides mothers). Hitler, had the ability to convince and manipulate citizens with his charismatic skills, which is how he gained power over Germany.