preview

Pros And Cons Of Female Circumcision

Better Essays

Introduction In our society today, they’re arguments surrounding the similarities and differences between male vs. female circumcision. In some instances people generalize circumcision to stem from a cultural, religious or medical base. Occasionally people view female circumcision as abuse and unruly; male circumcision is viewed as a rite of passage. Often people would suggest how female circumcision is worst than males due to females having more health issues behind the procedure than males. This paper will evaluate both sides of the argument, and shed light on the pros and cons of male vs. female circumcision.
Religious & Cultural Standpoints
According to Perera, Bridgewater, Thavaneswaran,Maddern , (2009), states how male circumcision …show more content…

Some of these cultures will not view these men as an adult if he refuses to participate in this cultural ceremony. These cultures that partake in the ceremonies range from african and asian cultures. For example, a male getting circumcised is equally important as to obtaining a high school diploma.
Circumcision is used as stepping stone to success. In numerous instances cultures and religions are tied together regarding male circumcision. As a result of Harbinson, he states the device that is used in the jewish culture is called “jewish circumcision shield” (p.247). For example, male circumcision is viewed in many cultures as a spiritual responsibility; and displays an importance to the community such as Jewish and Muslim societies (Perera, Bridgewater, Thavaneswaran,& Maddern,p.2240). If the male doesn’t comply his rights and privileges can be revoked from the culture. In this case circumcision for males means upholding the family honor and spiritual acknowledgement. By the same token, women in different nations endure similar treatment and scrutiny regarding female circumcision. Consequently, Green (2005), explains in order to be statused in her …show more content…

Both males and females can experience tissue damage, disfigurement, and sexual dysfunction after the procedure. According to Bossio, Pukall & Steele (2014), explains how after circumcision males experience effects like erectile dysfunction, loss of sensitivity due to foreskin being removed (2853). For instance , the negatives when adult males undergo the surgical procedure some don’t enjoy masturbation as much, or it the penis decreases the ability to orgasm, but this stems from adult men. On the other hand, studies show that male circumcision can have some medical benefits, and the leading factor for parents to have the procedure done to their sons. According to Stehr (2012), discloses how having the foreskin serves as a protective mechanism from calluses developing opposed to being circumcised (p.22) For example, the foreskin provide a cover for the head of the penis so it doesn’t undergo friction. Also with any surgery being done they're risks of infection and severe bleeding. According to Krill, Palmer & Palmer (2011), displays studies that were conducted at the Massachusetts General Hospital, experienced a 7.4% of circumcision complications; for example out of 5,521 procedures done 23 demonstrated complications with the Plastibell device (Complications section, para 1&2). Studies imply that the device choice can contribute to the risk factors relating to circumcision

Get Access