Some people believe in love at first sight, while others believe it takes time and effort to actually love someone. Yet arranged marriage is a bit different, In the arranged world, they say marriage comes first and love comes later. Sometimes it’s a perfect happily ever after and other times it’s a disaster. In both "The Disappearance" by Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni and Jag Mundhra's movie "Provoked" it shows how arranged marriage amongst other things is just a recipe for disaster, especially for the wives who plunge head first into the hole that is marriage. In the movie and short story, it concentrates on the clash of cultural values and the gender related double standard that comes from a cultural arranged marriage.
Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni
…show more content…
Both women start off as an ordinary couple with a loving husband and a beautiful home yet eventually they feel trapped in a marriage they don’t want to be in. The are practically considered property to the man and he is to do whatever he pleases with her. When Deepak held the iron on Kiranjeet's Face, he says she is a worthless "cunt " she is less than anything and he can do whatever he wants . In "The disappearance " he gives her permission to go out and walk so that she can have "time for herself" (Divakaruni) He allows her to do such simple things and thinks of himself as a "honest man " a "good husband " He lets her choose the color, furniture and what places to go visit yet when it comes to things that aren't so materialistic both husbands forbid them, they don’t allow them to continue their education or dress in more westernized clothes or even get a job. The husband in "The disappearance " requested a smart wife, but when she asks to "go back to school " he says "NO" (Divakaruni) When Kiranjeet asked to continue her studies and fulfill her mother's dream about being a lawyer he beat her . They are both to follow their husband's wishes without any argument . These are the customs they are to follow …show more content…
Yet Kiranjeet Did not find freedom until she was locked up in jail. The wife from "The Disappearance '" did not find freedom until she ran away from everything, even her own son and faked her disappearance. She knew her son would be safe, but she haunted her husband for years to come when she took the jewelry from the bank and proved how big his pride really was. He knew she realized, but he couldn't tell anyone or he would be known as the man who can't control his own wife. She staged her own clever disappearance, but she made sure to let her husband that she left him. When Kiranjeet was locked up she got everything she ever wanted. Her cellmate was teaching her to perfect her English, she was making friends, she was learning to defend herself. Ten years of torture and Jail was the first time she was truly happy and
In years past, the American Dream for most young girls’ is to grow up and be married to Prince Charming and to “Live Happily Ever After!” Although this may be expected - it is rarely fulfilled. Marriage is the legal and binding union between a man and woman. Yet when couples marry, they vow to stay by their partner’s side ‘till death do us part.’ Currently that vow seems to have little or no value in today’s society. The current statistics for survival of marriage are quite grim. The divorce rate in the United States is somewhere between 50 percent and a startling 67 percent. (KSL News) One contributing factor the growing epidemic of divorce is the parting of different family
If one does not require a marriage for their love to grow or even transpire, then why do it at all and for what purpose? With a look at “The Arranged Marriage” by
Jhumpa Lahiri’s short story, “A Temporary Matter,” presents the failing marriage of an Indian couple, Shoba and Shukumar. Lahiri illustrates how the grief of losing someone can lead to a broken relationship. Shukumar and Shoba have been ignoring each other since Shoba had a miscarriage. The tragedy changes the way they treat each other. Their grief makes both of them become two different people. A temporary matter has forced them to communicate with each other and since then, Shukumar and Shoba are comfortable talking to each other and even making love with each other. This temporary matter has somehow temporarily reconnected them together. Jhumpa Lahiri intentionally uses the symbols of darkness, light, house, the baby and neighbors to represent a broken relationship of a married couple.
What is an arranged marriage? An arranged marriage by definition is a marriage planned and agreed to by the families or guardians of the bride and groom. The amount of input a bride or groom has is based off the type of arranged marriage. In the traditional arranged marriage the bride and groom have significant input and are not forced. Arranged marriage is a sensitive topic as it involves the values, beliefs and core characteristics of many. There are multiple views on arranged marriage, both positive and negative. Here in the west many have negative opinions on arranged marriages. Arranged marriage can be researched and analyzed from an anthropological, psychological and sociological perspective. Through the three perspectives, many distinctive differences and similarities between arranged marriage and other types of marriage such as love/choice marriage can be seen. This research essay will analyze arranged marriage from the perspective of all three social sciences and show how arranged marriage is just as good if not better than love/choice marriage from the perspective of all three social sciences.
The book mentions about the mental confusions, insecurities and the effort to understand their spouses. The writer has expressed simple and usual emotions of a womanhood, fidelity and family. A tint of Indian culture is reflected in each chapter indicating how a bridegroom and groom select each other, the nature of an Indian woman and how she takes up challenges in her life, reconciling the roles of a daughter, an ex-wife, a wife and a mother, the strength of the human spirit and their passion to survive and fight for a good life. It also features the distinctive qualities of Indian relatives highlighting their interest in an individual’s marital life and how offensive it is to the society to find a married woman talking to an unknown man. The book also focuses on the pain of a mother to see her unhealthy
Marriage has been a heated controversy for the past few years because people often marry for the wrong reasons. Anyone who thinks of an ideal marriage would think of two people loving each other and sharing a personal bond or goals together. Marriage is regularly defined as the legally or formally recognized union of two lovers as partners in a personal relationship. This definition remarks there is an actual connection between two people in marriage, but do people actually consider this when committing to “love” and “support” their partners forever? As research and studies have shown, people ultimately get married for many reasons, except love. This philosophy can be easily applied to the short poem, “Marriage” by Gregory Corso. In this emotional poem, the author argues marriage is more effectively understood or known for culture and convenience rather than through the abstract considerations of love. Here, we can identify people generally decide to marry for the incorrect reasons, for instance the story of the author himself. Corso finds himself confused multiple times, wondering if he should marry to not be lonely, for tradition and for his physical and mental health. He disregards love, a relationship or a connection with his future wife. General ways of convenience like loneliness, health and economic status between cultural stereotypes and religion are usually the true reasons of why people chose to have the commitment of marriage with another person.
Established with Adam and Eve, still surviving, marriage is the oldest institution known. Often the climax of most romantic movies and stories, whether it may be ‘Pride and Prejudice’ or ‘Dil Wale Dulhaniya Ley Jaein Gey’, marriage has a universal appeal. It continues to be the most intimate social network, providing the strongest and most frequent opportunity for social and emotional support. Though, over the years, marriage appears to be tarnished with high divorce rates, discontentment and infidelity, it is still a principal source of happiness in the lives of respective partners. Although marriage is perceived as a deeply flawed institution serving more the needs of the society than those of the individuals, nevertheless, marriage is
The stark divide between love and marriage shown right the way through cannot be comprehended fully by the twenty-first century reader: in today’s society marriage and love are mutually exclusive - you very rarely get one
Kavitha from “Kavitha and Mustafa” is so deeply unhappy with Vinod that she risks her life to escape the train overtaken by bandits. Vinod, Kavitha’s husband, shows no respect for Kavitha. They have been in an arranged marriage for ten years, yet they still never show any love or appreciation each other. Although Kavitha makes many sacrifices for Vinod, he still chooses to be careless, and “. . . hardly even asked her about herself . . .” (11). Vinod makes fun of her beliefs and slaps her when she talks back to him. When they are on the train together, Kavitha realizes that they probably won’t make it out together. The bandits in the berth were searching everyone for their jewelry and other valuables; she knows that if she tries to run away,
Both Krishna and Leela loses an important member in their family. While Leela continues her normal routine, the life of Krishnan is thrown out of control. It takes a lot of effort on his part and the guidance of his late wife for him to come to terms with his wife‟s
In the opening sequence of the film, the viewer is immediately presented with an image of marriage as entirely contractual: "Today he married me to a man I've not yet met." The protagonist, although she has already been established as strong-willed and non-conforming, is accepting but not altogether optimistic about the arrangement. The viewer also learns that she
Marriage is a union that has been around for as long as humans have walked the earth. The human race depends upon the union of its members, and as such, the subject of marriage has been an issue that receives more intense scrutiny and attention than many would likely believe. In today's day and age, with humanity continuing to move in a modern direction, many argue that marriage is a union that should be entered into freely and should be based exclusively on the love between two people. However, I argue that arranged marriage, which has taken place throughout the ages and throughout the world, is a union that offers its observers a marriage based in support, longevity and love, and is an institution that should not be frowned upon.
When life becomes unbearable between a women an her husband, they may think of divorce as being a fair solution for both of them to get their “independence” and live a normal life, they may even think that it is suitable for their children. However, this is not the case , divorce may have some serious consequences that can affect the whole society .
“Made in heaven, found on earth - marriages are a new beginning according to some and the final end for others” (“Arranged Marriage”, 2009). Marriage is religiously and socially a huge responsibility and its failure could affect societies negatively. Arranged marriages are planned by families, when the bride and the groom are chosen either randomly from a wedding or by family relatives. Especially in the Gulf countries, certain families consider such marriages of high social importance. Arranged marriages in this region have a low expectancy of success. Forced marriages, short engagements and incompatibility between potential couples are the main causes of divorce in arranged marriages in the Gulf region.
Changes can be made at any time as long as it is for the sake of our happiness. However, how can Indian women in this movie pursuit their happiness when they think they are deemed to suffer after their husbands’ death as a symbol of devotion to husband?