preview

Puerto Rico Debt Crisis Summary

Decent Essays

Structuralism in the Context of the Puerto Rican Debt Crisis Diane Lourdes Dick’s (2015) piece on “U.S Tax Imperialism in Puerto Rico” argues that U.S. domain over Puerto Rico’s tax and fiscal policies constitutes the destruction of Puerto Rico’s economic system. She states that “Puerto Rico’s ambiguous political status and historic lac of formal legal process for restructuring its public debts are partly responsible for a mounting crisis, which has inspired hand-wringing and speculation on Wall Street” (Dick 2015, p.8). Dick phrases this lack of input as U.S. tax imperialism, similar to that of Pierluisi and Backiel, since it is based on the argument that the island’s lack of a voice in its fiscal matters contributes to its fiscal status (Dick 2015). She states that the traditional narrative on U.S. policies presents them as “generous and benevolent compared to Puerto Rican tax and economic policies, which are portrayed as grasping and even guileful” (Dick 2015, p.7). However, she claims that the island’s current …show more content…

Crisis, Colonialism and Globalization” (2016) furthers the structuralist claim by arguing that the debt should have been mitigated prior to the establishment of the fiscal control board (Pantoja 2016). “In order to cover the structural deficit and sustain the economic expansion, the government borrowed money to finance public works, issue substantial service contracts, and pay for operational expenses” (Pantoja 2016, p. 61). Moreover, Pantoja signals the fact that "a long-term solution to the Puerto Rican crisis must deal with the issues that brought the island to this point: the collapse of a colonial protectionist politico-economic system in a post-colonial world” (Pantoja 2016, p. 68). His analysis was written before the announcement of P.R.O.M.E.S.A, which serves to explain his argument that debt restructuration is the only viable option for the government of Puerto

Get Access