To: Chip and Charles Carroway, owner of CCL From: Rose Reddick, CGA Date: April 20th, 20X3 Subject: Accounting issues analysis CCL is a CCPC and follows ASPE. It is the second year that my firm auditing for CCL. It is CCL’s responsibility to correctly record accounting transaction and preparing financial reports. Manager should be unbiased to fairly present financial reports within GAAP. After careful analysis, I presented several accounting issues and related analysis as follow. Issue1: Stock option on tax implications Since CCL is a CCPC, there are special tax rules for the company. The stock option benefits are not taxable at date of purchase, but it is taxable when the shares are disposed. For employee …show more content…
Issue2: Financing option The debate is about whether to choose loan or equity. In terms of the loan option, CCL would be able to claim tax deductible for the interest payment. However, CCL currently has tight debt covenant. If loan option were chose, debt covenant might be violated and bank might not allow for the issuing new loan or might cancel the existing loan, or might establish unreasonable loan terms for CCL. Interest payment might also limit cash flow, which might impact R&D success of CCL, creates going concern issue. Regarding going public, CCL would be able to obtain a long-lasting and abundance capital resource without any fixed cash outflow happening. Current debt covenant would not be violated because no additional debts would be added on to the current debt position. However, CCL’s ownership would be diluted and control would be weakened because partial voting common shares of CCL will be given to shareholders. Large amount of expenditure regarding to going public would occur. In addition, CCL becomes a public company meaning it needs to report financial statement under IFRS, which would bring a lot of modifications regarding financial reporting and employee trainings because IFRS is more strict than ASPE and current accountant has no associated IFRS expertise in preparation of financial statement. Moreover, CCL would miss SBD deduction on first $500,000 of Active business income. Therefore, CCL would
If the tax rate of shareholders is higher, it would be better to keep the cash internally and invest but if LT’s tax rate is higher the
This step involves short and long term debt equity analysis. The proportion of equity capital depends on the possessing and additional funds will be raised. The choice of the source of funds the company has are the issue of shares and debentures, loans to be taken from banks and financial institutions and public deposits to be drawn in form of bonds. The choice will depend on relative merits and demerits of each source and period of financing. The management of the investment funds is key in allocating that the funds are going in the correct place. The profits that are made can be down in two ways dividend declaration which includes identifying the rate of dividends and retained profits in which the volume has to be decided which will depend upon expansion and diversification of the company. The management of cash is another important function. Cash is needed for all different aspects of the company such as payment of salaries, overhead and bills. All of these are important in a company and how successful the financial aspect is going to be.The financial management practices include capital structure decision, investment appraisal techniques, dividend policy, working capital management and financial performance assessment. A company needs to have well financial in order to be successful. “A company that sells well but has poor financial management can fail.” (Johnston)
CML's equity ratio increased to 0.4 and correspondingly debt ratio decreased to 0.15 from 2001 to 2005. Generally it is a good trend, even though there has been a decrease in equity ratio in 2005 from 0.45 to 0.40 and an increase in debt ratio from 2004 to 2005, it may be due to the acquisition from US group KKR. However, in 2005, equity is almost three times debt, which means the capital structure is still in good condition.
The company position is strong enough so its better that company should use debt financing instead of equity financing.
Wells Fargo shows a much higher profitability ratio than Samsung, with over 8X that of Samsung. This is to be expected as services are typically more profitable than hardware sales which operate on leaner margins. Wells Fargo also outperforms Samsung significantly on return on sales with over 25X better performance. This again is attributable to better margins on services than hardware. Wells Fargo has a much stronger return on equity than Samsung with a Dupont ratio over 5X higher than Samsung's. Samsung has a stronger financial leverage ratio than Wells Fargo with almost 20% lower ratio for Samsung. Samsung also has a much lower total asset turnover than Wells Fargo. This is attributable to the quick turnover of assets in the manufacturing industry compared to the slow turnover of assets in the financial services sector.
1. How does PPLS create value for its customers? What are the critical risks that it has to manage well?
According to the fact of this case, Parent Co. (Parent) wholly owns Poor Son Co. (Poor Son) as a legal subsidiary, and both of them all nonpublic companies. However, in January 2007 Poor Son filed a voluntary bankruptcy under Chapter 11 of the U.S. bankruptcy code because of its inability of meet obligations as they became due. Then, Parent claimed the loss of control of Poor Son and deconsolidated Poor Son from its financial statement. Through the bidding process in May 2009, Poor Son and OtherCo, the winning sponsor, filed a joint plan of reorganization to the bankruptcy court, but the plan was rescinded by OtherCo later due to significant market value shrink of Poor Son. After that, the
Assess the degree to which the firm’s accounting reflects the underlying business reality. Identify accounting distortions and evaluate their impact on profits and the sustainability of profits.
CCL is currently looking at an initial public offering (IPO) and long term debt as two options to help finance the new research and development (R&D) of new products. The bank loan can provided financial stability but will have the interest repaid over a longer time is higher and would be tax deductible. Banks may
For future cash flows, evaluation is done with WACC rate which consists from cost of equity and cost of debt in a weighted average. In this case, using cost of equity is not appropriate since we doesn’t know cost of debt and weights of equity and debt, it doesn’t reflect the actual rate for WACC.
Feedback: Management accounting is the preparation and use of accounting information systems to achieve the organization's objectives by supporting decision makers inside the enterprise. LO 4
When a company is incorporated it is treated as a separate legal entity distinct from its promoters, directors, members, and employees, which confers the benefit of not being responsible for the companies debt on the members on the company. However even though a company is a separate legal entity and it attains the advantage of not laying the responsibility of company’s debt on the
On 1 July 2011, Kookaburra Ltd acquired an item of plant at a cost of $200 000. The plant has an
By: Charn Gek Cheng, Chiang Soo Ling, Kummar Sokali Muthu Mogan, Lee Siew Fen Samantha
Article 26 of CCL: The registered capital of a limited liability company shall be the total amount of capital contributions subscribed by all the shareholders as registered at the relevant company registration authority. The aggregate amount of the first capital contribution made by all the shareholders shall not be less than 20 percent of the registered capital, nor shall it be less than the statutory minimum amount of registered capital. The remaining capital contributions shall be paid up in full by the shareholders within two years from the day when the company is established, or may be paid up in full within five years, in the case of an investment company.