preview

Questions and Answers on Criminal Procedure

Good Essays

1. Does the information included in the warrant application amount to Probable Cause? Why or why not? Probably not. This would be defined as an anticipatory search warrant, but the information provided by the confidential informant includes statements that are mostly vague: Dory was "planning to sell" Golden Starfish within an open-ended date, she "probably will deliver" the stolen merchandise at some point, and she "usually rents a room" at the specific hotel named. None of this qualifies as reliable recent information as to criminal activity; as for proposed or future criminal activity, there are not sufficient facts here to indicate an event that would be sufficient to qualify as a "triggering condition". According to the US Supreme Court's decision in U.S. v Grubbs (2006), what is required in an anticipatory search warrant is a triggering condition that would permit the execution of the warrant on the fair probability that contraband would be discovered if the search were executed no such condition appears to be included here, when the best that is offered for a "triggering condition" is that Dory has rented a room. The fact that the detective overheard mention of the Golden Starfish through the door is irrelevant to the establishment of probable cause for the warrant, though. 2. Of what significance, if any, is the two-week period for serving the warrant? Ordinarily a search warrant cannot be served if "stale" information is included in the search warrant

Get Access