Comparing and Contrasting Soldier’s Heart and Red Badge of Courage Charley and Henry have many similarities. They are both young soldiers in the Civil War fighting for the Union. As the war begins they are both in for a rude awakening for their decisions. They were excited to go, but now they are seeing the reality of their decisions and the excitement is wearing off. The war is changing both of them. War changes people in many different ways. Charley and Henry are very similar but they also have many differences. Henry is close to many people, but Charley has not created a bond with any of the other soldiers. In the beginning Charley was so excited and loved feeling like a man, but now he doesn’t know if he can make it through another battle
He listens in on the battle, and to much of his surprise, he hears cheering from what’s left of his regiment. He then takes off into the woods in anger. While running through the woods his conscience begins to speak to him. He keeps telling himself that he is a coward and a deserter. Out of guilt, Henry runs back to the battle site, and meets again with his regiment. These actions showed Henry’s maturity and desire to be a war hero.
Henry’s confidence does not last for a long time. The realities of the battle become a reality and cause his fear and doubt to reappear. Henry goes from being happy because he was able to fight the enemy in the first battle to being anxious at the beginning of a second
Henry joined the army and returned back home a changed man. Before the war, Henry was happy, carefree, and full of life. He also shared a great bond with his brother Lyman, but after he returned from
First, one should focus on the language and Henry's ethos. The soldiers are burdened with the thought of a
As he is walking, a few soldiers that seems to be fleeing run into him. As Henry tries to stop them to ask what’s been happening, one of the soldiers swings at him with a rifle, opening a bloody gash on the top of his head. After a long while of waiting, a friendly soldier finds him and leads him back to camp, where a friend tends to his wound. After a few days of waiting, they come across another battle. This time Henry doesn’t flee, instead he thinks about all the people who have fought and died in the war, and decides to do the same: fight. Not only for the glory this time, but for the people he was
First, Henry might have been scared. He saw what happened in the first battle and it affected him in a way it didn't the others. This was the first time he fought in a war or battle with other men. He made friends with some of the soldiers in his regiment. If he stuck
The Civil War officially started in 1861, yet problems between the North and the South date back as far as the early 1830s. The North was infuriated over slavery after a woman by the name of Harriet Beecher Stowe published her book Uncle Tom's Cabin. Stowe's book analyzed the life of a slave in an astonishing and realistic way. It caused many people to join the Union. Then the war began in July of 1861 when a Confederate army met with a Federal army at Manassen, Virginia. Many battles were fought until finally the north was victorious. Slavery was abolished, and the federal government's power was set as supreme power over all the land.
In today’s issue, we will be covering all the major events that have transpired in The Red Badge of Courage as a sort of “catch-up” for new readers. Firstly, it all began when young Henry Fleming enlisted in the Union Army, wanting to fight for his country. He expects war to be thrilling and exciting, and for him to come back a decorated hero, praised by the town. However, it starts out far from his dreams. Instead, his regiment is only told to stay where they are, drilling and training over and over again and abstaining from any combat. Finally, his wish is granted as his regiment moves out, but not in the way they expected. The “moving” simply consisted of them stopping in one area, settling down, then being ordered to move again, repeating
In the first battle, Henry fights along side the other soldiers. At this time, Henry is feeling confidant in his fighting skills and counted on his fellow soldiers to do their job. The narrator says, "He became not a man but a member. He felt that something of which he was apart- a regiment, an army, a cause, or a country - was in a crisis. He was welded into a common personality which was dominated by a single desire". In this quote, it talks about how he feels that he believes in his regiment. He isn't so selfish, he believes he is no longer an individual with regiments, they work as a whole person. In the second battle, it's different, he flees with the regiment.
Henry is also listening to the orders from his Captian who is standing behind him who is shouting encouragement to the troops and begins to feel part of the war machine. “He suddenly lost concern for himself and forgot to look at a menacing fate. He became not a man but a member.” He continues to fire and reload even as others a dying around him. After the battle is over and the regiment holds its ground the soldiers are excited and happy they have survived, they have beaten back the enemy. He is encouraged by the beauty of the flags blowing in the wind and the beauty of the sky and land. Henry feels he is a man he has passed the ultimate test. However he realizes that he is one skirmish in a series of
Henry didn’t think like Charlie when it came to the war. He was a coward and frightened of the war, and Henry ran with the wounded. He actually pretended to be wounded. Henry was of age for the war, but he didn’t think the war would be as frightening at first. Henry wasn’t ready
No, Life in the army is not what he would be expecting, because he wasn’t going to get used to the fact that there wasn’t going to be good food and the fact that there weren’t good doctors. He didn’t like the fact that the doctors weren’t that good with helping the sick and the hurt/wounded. Charley was a brave and tough soldier who made it to Gettysburg, where he died. He didn’t like to do all of the training, all he wanted to do was fight and do the real stuff. At the beginning he and his mother were arguing, but not bad enough to keep him from going to war. He didn't expect to be gone that long, but he knew he had to do it for his mother to make her proud and help her
Life in the army was not what Charley expected because automatically when he lied about his age and was allowed in the war even though he wanted to join the war because so he could prove that he is a man and not a little boy. When the Union went to Fort Snelling they did not have any uniforms for him only black pants that were so short that they showed his calves, grey socks and a black felt hat that was cheap to to the point that the sprinkle it drooped over his face. he did experience some good in the war one when the Union was on there way to Manassas he got to ride on a train with nice cushions and good food, but while he was still traveling he saw some “poor” farms and children who were barely dressed.
This is yet again another quote by the narrator. In this quote Henry gets the feeling that, in battle, one is not an individual as a part of a larger organism. Henry feels like he has earned his spot in the regiment and feels now like the newest member. He was part of this "common personality", a part of a "subtle battle brotherhood.” He understands that he can do very little as one guy; instead, the entire regiment acts as one and either wins or loses. The other men come together or form into one and fight together as a unit. However, Henry demonstrates that a soldier might still focus on his individual response to the war and split from the body. Henry leaves his regiment when he thinks they have lost, and ventures out on his own. He is
He described that he couldn’t escape even if he wanted to. Through this analogy, the reader can see that Henry is reducing the soldiers to unthinking, unfeeling machines, performing their duty without taking into account the threat of injury or death. As he looks around at the faces of the rest of the soldiers in his regiment, he notices their focused commitment to the firing of their rifles. He wonders if he is the only one faced with questions of morality. While the regiment began to advance, Henry was shocked to receive a packet of letters from Wilson, who feared he would die in battle. After the battle, he is glad that he made it through the first day. He begins to lose the romantic vision of war by seeing the realities, but he starts lying to himself about who is really is.