Essay on Reflexive Embodied Empathy
‘Reflexive embodied empathy’: a phenomenology of participant-researcher intersubjectivity
By: Linda Finlay
Acknowledgements: My grateful thanks go to Scott Churchill for reminding me to return to Husserl’s work on intersubjectivity to better anchor my concept of ‘reflexive embodied empathy’. I am also indebted to Maree Burns who first drew my attention to the idea of embodied reflexivity.
Address for correspondence: 29 Blenheim Terrace, Scarborough, North Yorkshire, United Kingdom, YO12 7HD Tel: + 44 1723 501833 Email: L.H.Finlay@open.ac.uk
Abstract
In this paper I’m advocating a research process which involves …show more content…
To define and explicate this concept, I start by exploring some of the literature on empathy. There is an extensive empirical literature on empathy in the fields of neuroscience (see Thompson, 2001) and social psychology (see Davis, 1994). However, I confine my discussion here to the equally extensive (though sometimes overlooked) literature from phenomenology. Here, I draw on a range of theoretical ideas but the philosophical ideas of Husserl (1928/1989) on intersubjectivity and of Merleau-Ponty (1964/1968) on ‘embodiment as intertwining’ are particularly influential. While the focus in this literature review is on empathy, concepts related to embodiment and reflexivity are integral.
The literature review is followed by an analysis of the concept of reflexive embodied empathy in practice. I use three examples of significant moments from various hermeneutic phenomenological research projects to demonstrate reflexive analysis of my own embodied, intersubjective relationships with participants. I characterize these moments of reflective involvement with the data as fluid, interpermeating ‘layers’ whereby different dimensions of experience are called to the fore. Three co-existing layers of reflexivity are described: • connecting-of the Other’s embodiment to our own • acting-into the Other’s
-
Essay on The Role of the Reflexive Ethnographer
1252 Words | 6 PagesThe Role of the Reflexive Ethnographer Works Cited Missing The role of the reflexive ethnographer has been constantly defined and redefined since the beginning of the study of anthropology. The use of reflexivity has and will always be questioned in anthropology. Malinowski, who was a pioneer in the field of anthropology, discouraged the use of reflexivity; he, instead, believed that anthropology was scientific and could produce “concrete evidence” (Malinowski 17). Reflexivity is way…
-
The Devlopment of Reflexive Anthropology Essay
743 Words | 3 PagesThe Devlopment of Reflexive Anthropology Reflexive anthropology has pressured scholoars to recognize their own biases and look increasingly inwards when studying “other” cultures. Reflexive anthropology is a break away from the traditional study of a clearly defined “us” and “them,” that seeks to shift towards indentification rather than difference. It attempts to uncover the politics behind ethnography. Reflexivity shows how “we” are effected by “others”, and how “others” are effected by…
-
The Need for Empathy in a Therapeutic Relationship
723 Words | 3 PagesIs Empathy a prerequisite for a good Therapeutic relationship? If so, what is the optimal degree of Empathy required for a positive Therapeutic outcome? In the recent years, much emphasis is placed on understanding what "ingredients" in Therapeutic relationship contribute to a positive outcome. Many researchers have attempted to separate essential aspects of the Therapeutic relationship. Rogers (1957) quoted three essential aspects that were vital to attain a "psychological climate" in where a client…
-
Art and Empathy
1536 Words | 7 Pagesdid not allow men to be men. Holocaust art, the “Tale of the Sprinter” by Sudeep Pagedar, and Vladek Spiegelman in the memoirs Maus by Art Spiegelman are examples of how men suffered during the Holocaust and the amount of empathy produced from the suffering of these men. Empathy is the ability to see something from somebody else's point of view and to walk a mile in their shoes if you will. Men are very prideful individuals who are very dominating members of society. The atrocity of the Holocaust…
-
Essay on Reflexive Embodied Empathy
9936 Words | 40 PagesMethods issue #4 The Humanistic Psychologist ‘Reflexive embodied empathy’: a phenomenology of participant-researcher intersubjectivity By: Linda Finlay Acknowledgements: My grateful thanks go to Scott Churchill for reminding me to return to Husserl’s work on intersubjectivity to better anchor my concept of ‘reflexive embodied empathy’. I am also indebted to Maree Burns who first drew my attention to the idea of embodied reflexivity. Address for correspondence:…
-
Essay Empathy in to Kill a Mockingbird
743 Words | 3 PagesEmpathy in To Kill A Mockingbird Empathy is the theme which connects the reader with the characters in the novel To Kill a Mockingbird; the experiences of the characters in this novel show us the significance of empathy as a theme. Harper Lee writes about the experiences which Scout and Jem undergo in learning to be empathetic, while Atticus and Tom Robinson are two of the key characters who, at the time of the novel already possessed the ability to be empathetic. Atticus is the character who displays…
-
Fashion and Reflexive Advertising Essay example
3369 Words | 14 PagesAbsolut ad also mocks its own ubiquity. It refers to a whole series of ads in which Absolut brands virtually all aspects of everyday life. The advertisers are able to disguise the product with cucumbers, as the consumer is already familiar with the reflexive conventions of Absolut advertisements, and is able to connect them back to the product. Absolut legitimates the ad and itself by engaging in self-deprecation about its own signifying potential (Goldman and Papson, 113). The ad obscures the product's…
-
Listening With Understanding and Empathy
557 Words | 2 PagesListening With Understanding and Empathy From the activities, it is quite easy to understand the key aspects of listening with understanding and empathy. First, one does not have to necessarily agree with the other people's ideas but understand where they are coming from. In the same line, one is able to assume the other persons position, this way, it is easy to overcome egocentrism, focusing on the other person rather than self. By listening with understanding and empathy, one able to repeat accurately…
-
Balancing Solidarity and Empathy
972 Words | 4 PagesLife” author Mary Sarton explained that, “Human intercourse often demands that we soften the edge of perception, or withdraw at the very instant of personal truth for fear of hurting, or being inappropriately present” (42). Others argue that having empathy for others can be better for you and for the world, in the memoir by author Azar Nafisi “Mysterious Connections that Link Us Together”, says “Through imagination and our desire for rappart we transcend our limitations, freshen our eyes, and are able…
-
Social Empathy Essay
957 Words | 4 Pagessupport and resources to help them when they fall on hard times or experience tragedies like death and illness. Overall, social media is an exciting new world that changes as it grows and it will be up to society to utilize it for good. A lack of empathy is found in the growing trend of cyber-bullying. "Jumping off GW bridge sorry." That was the last status update Tyler Clementi ever posted to his Facebook page before leaping to his death off the George Washington Bridge in New York City. About a…
More about Essay on Reflexive Embodied Empathy
-
Essay on The Role of the Reflexive Ethnographer
1252 Words | 6 Pages -
The Devlopment of Reflexive Anthropology Essay
743 Words | 3 Pages -
The Need for Empathy in a Therapeutic Relationship
723 Words | 3 Pages -
Art and Empathy
1536 Words | 7 Pages -
Essay on Reflexive Embodied Empathy
9936 Words | 40 Pages -
Essay Empathy in to Kill a Mockingbird
743 Words | 3 Pages -
Fashion and Reflexive Advertising Essay example
3369 Words | 14 Pages -
Listening With Understanding and Empathy
557 Words | 2 Pages -
Balancing Solidarity and Empathy
972 Words | 4 Pages -
Social Empathy Essay
957 Words | 4 Pages