Robert Hunter West. Milton and the Angels.
The University of Georgia: The University of Georgia Press, 1955.
Robert H. West’s Milton and the Angels consists of ten chapters which are divided into two main sections. The first half of the book expounds upon the history of the study of angels in the Western hemisphere and then in England specifically. The second half of the book examines the titular subject of John Milton’s propositions on angels. The final chapter of the work, reiterates and summarizes all nine previous chapters to reveal their larger purpose and significance within the book itself and within Milton’s entire career. Through the structure, West outlines that he “tried to give an orderly and proportioned, though elementary,
…show more content…
(13-14)
While each of the different traditions had very different beliefs on the details of angelology, such as the exemplified Catholic and Protestant differences, each agreed upon the necessity of angelology, which West reveals through the words of John Calvin. Beyond the question of the rank, West expounds upon controversies about the nature, purpose, substance, ability, activity, and humanity of angels throughout every age of history from the Greek and Roman empires to Milton’s seventeenth-century England to both contextualize the book’s subject for readers and to illuminate the significance and depth behind John Milton’s own literary representation of angels.
In chapters six and seven, West introduces Milton’s angelology and examines the choices he makes throughout his literature to maintain a specific representation of the angels and other supernatural subjects. Specifically, West identifies three problems Milton had to overcome in writing Paradise Lost, which involved balancing the need for literary description with the strict, biblical interpretation of angels hailed in Puritanism, deciding which opinions on angelology could be used to truthfully deduce the needed level of description, and broadly,
As a text written in the early middle ages, the Canon Episcopi by Regino of Prüm was revolutionary in the fact that it exemplified a growing skepticism for magic within the Christian community, and most importantly, it served as a strict call to arms for church officials to identify and eliminate practices of magic within parish communities. As a major theological text in the time where Christianity is finally solidifying doctrine, the Canon Episcopi should both draw upon existing ideas of its predecessors and shape the theological works of its successors. While the works of other theological minds show evidence of a common theme or influence, there is still extreme variability and sometimes even direct opposition to Regino’s themes. While
Biblical stories have been told over many centuries and can be found in many different forms. Artists have attempted to capture their versions of what these stories may have looked like. This essay will chronicle the similarities and differences between two different biblical accounts. The first biblical account is from Bernardino Jacopi Butinone’s The Massacre of The Innocents. A recreation of the Roman King Herod’s order to kill all first born son’s in order to kill Jesus before he could rise to power. The second biblical account is from Acislo Antonio Palomino de Castro y Velasco’s The Archangel Michael Defeating Satan. It is the story of Satan’s fall to hell by the order of God and the sword of Michael The Archangel. (Good summary and opening.)
In today’s world it is difficult to read any piece of literature that has not been at least minorly impacted by a piece of literature that has come before it. In fact, many stories published today incorporate elements of past works or reference them directly in a literary device known as allusion. One of the most commonly alluded to literary works is the Christian Bible, one of the oldest books to be published in the common era. Because the Bible is often alluded to in other literary works, it has been analyzed by countless scholars in many different ways. The most important way, that is, the way in which Norman W. Jones analyzes the Bible is in a literary manner. Because of this, this review will focus on Jones’s literary connections and the
Disobedience plays a key role in the unfolding of Milton’s poem. Satan disobeys God because God gave him free will, and causes Eve to disobey Adam, to disobey God.
In Early Modern England, the idea of men being superior to women was thought to be a God-given law. Sexism, though not yet coined as an English word at the time, was very prevalent in this time period and bled into the writing it produced. John Milton’s Paradise Lost is no exception to this, as it explores human sexuality and gender roles. It has been argued that when Adam and Eve are described as “Two of far nobler shape erect and tall,/ Godlike erect” (4.288-289) there is no distinction between the two, and that they are being portrayed, even by Satan, as equal. This is the reader’s first introduction to Eve who, based on these two lines from Paradise Lost, is Adam’s equivalent in power and in majesty. However, this passage cannot be isolated and taken as the theme of the entire epic work: Milton goes right on to convey “Milton’s idea that true freedom involves obedience to natural superiors” (Milton, p. 2009, footnote 9) by saying that there is “true authority in men” (4.295). Throughout Paradise Lost, Milton shows stark contrast between Adam and Eve, overall implying that Eve is a less perfect character. In his epic poem, Milton makes Eve out to be the misogynistic image of a simple, subordinate woman by showing her as being distanced from God, trained to be obedient to men, and conveying the negative outcomes that transpire when Eve is persuaded into making her own decision.
Jager’s work is an interpretive work that reflects history of the use of language as a trope. Using a book by Ernst Robert Curtius, he shows how the heart was used as a trope, but was deeply imbedded in interior writing that went back to ancient times. Also, to use more recent work, Jager quotes Jacques Derrida, when he said “a history of this metaphor had yet to be written”. Linking the trope with a platonic standpoint, I was reminded of St. Augustine. Jager, in a brief description, says that hearts and books were things, which symbolized different signs. The things were the hearts and books, while the sign was that the hearts and books represented a concept of knowledge, truth, and totality.
John Milton’s “Paradise Lost” is a text from the British Literature era that was written in 1667. This text constructs identity beyond societal norms in because it deals with the first two human beings, Adam and Eve. Milton illustrates identity beyond societal norms with Adam and Eve’s behavior. This behavior is shown in Milton’s book IV of “Paradise Lost”.
According to the given topic, the two types of angels Good and Bad have been described with Biblical references. The existence of angels and their creation has also been supported with the references taken from Bible. In this thesis, the explanation does not only restrict to the explanation of the thesis statement but it also provides evidences as to how this thesis can be supported. This work on thesis also covers the related areas when it comes to the discussion of angels. The need for extensively describing these areas such as the history of Christian art and its evolution, the influence of other religions on Christianity was important because it indirectly states the representation of angels in Christian art and the idea behind the representation. The different forms of representation that were used in Christian art also describe how angels were symbolized and how they were interpreted through Biblical statements. In this thesis, several references from bible have been given to support the idea of angels possessing no winds and human like characteristics. As this is the main idea of the thesis statement, several interrelated topics have been discussed. This thesis also supports evidences from modern formations of art. The new forms of art also wrongly develop the interpretation of angels as humans with wings and so clear evidences have been given in opposition to that. The problems that were faced in this thesis were that of clear
This paper seeks to compare two theologians, one male, one female, one Trinitarian and one mythological, Thomas F. Torrance and Sallie McFague.
John Milton’s Paradise Lost in an attempt to explain the ways of god to an, portrayed a god who is just and forgiving, but selfish. He is a contradictory figure, whose actions cannot be understood from a human perspective, but through spiritual/logical reasoning. His contradictory behavior places God in a role of ambiguity; a character that places justice, obedience and grace before all else causes him to dole out strict punishments and offer forgiveness in the same manner. God, through the eyes of Satan is unsympathetic, imposing and arrogant authority. However, this “tyrannical” God is also the same character who allows Satan into paradise, and is portrayed to be loving, all knowing, and omnipotent. Milton’s God is not a tyrant, but a complex character whose questionable actions place
Milton's purpose in Paradise Lost is nothing less than to assert eternal providence and justify the ways of God to men - a most daunting task. For Milton to succeed in his endeavour, he has to unravel a number of theologiccal thorns that have troubled christian philosophers for centuries. Since his epic poem is, essentially, a twelve book argument building to a logical conclusion - the 'justification of the ways of God to men' - he will necessarily have to deal with these dogmatic problems, and, in doing so, reveal his own take on the Christian theology.
Paradise Lost is a story of Genesis told as it normally would be, but with a protagonist focus on Satan. The story is told largely with Satan being favorably portrayed and God having little presence other than cursing things, which convinces the audience that Satan’s view of God as a tyrant may not be too far off. Still, Satan is portrayed as the villain of the story. However, he has characteristics of a classical hero; including flaws that make the audience relate to and feel sympathy for him. By using part of the black-and-white Genesis story which paints Satan as evil and juxtaposing a narrative which paints Satan as a sympathetic hero, Milton raises a question about morality that largely define the audience’s reaction to the story:
The theme of the 'heroic' in John Milton's Paradise Lost is one that has often been the focus of critical debate, namely in the debate surrounding which character is the 'true' hero of the poem. Most critics of the subject have, however, noted that the difficultly in defining the 'hero' of Milton's work is mainly due to our “vague understanding of what constitutes heroism”1 and the fact that “the term itself is equivocal”2. The 'vague' terming of what heroism can be defined as it what draws critics to disagree with one another over the nature of heroism, as Charles Martindale points out that there are 'different models of heroic', many of which Milton employs in his epic poem. To incorporate these different 'models' of the heroic into his
In his epic poem titled Paradise Lost, John Milton describes his work as a process to justify “the ways of God to men”. In terms of the personal and individual, Milton’s main concern was between a man’s relationship and God. With this, comes the very idea of free will itself. One can define free will as the ability and freedom to choose between different possible courses of action. Not only is free will portrayed in Adam and Eve, but is also associated with God, Christ, Satan and the fallen angels. Milton enables these characters to make their own choices and have their own consequences based on their own decisions and free will. Throughout the poem, John Milton supports this concept of acting freely under God, he shows the reader that choosing ones own actions freely and independently is way more substantial and becomes more meaningful to ones self. Each characters free will in this poem helps explain why having this freedom of choice is so important and crucial in expressing and becoming ones self.
The concept of revenge has prevailed as an integral component of literature, exemplified in Paradise Lost written by John Milton among other works. In Paradise Lost, Satan acts as the main proponent of revenge. The actions of his character create the basis for a Miltonic ideal of revenge, later modified by Emily Brontë and Mary Shelley. Wuthering Heights written by Brontë presents Heathcliff as a modernization of Satan. The characters share the experience of evolving from their lives as outcasts within their societies by means of revenge. The monster in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein romanticizes the Miltonic concept of revenge found in Paradise Lost. Although the creation and experiences of Satan and the monster differ, their premises for revenge become similar as the monster realizes his contempt toward his position within society and desires to retaliate. While the revenge exemplified in Paradise Lost shares similarities with both Wuthering Heights and Frankenstein, the origins of the desire for revenge, as well as its function within each book, differ due to changing life and literary styles following the writing of Paradise Lost. While the roots of the revenge of Satan lay in a desire for power, Heathcliff and the creature use revenge as a means to chase love and companionship.