preview

Romeo And Juliet Compare And Contrast Essay

Decent Essays

The original setting for Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet was the fair city of Verona located in Northern Italy during the 1300’s. Shakespeare chose this location due to it being well known for being for being a passionate as well as exotic city. This choice of setting allowed Shakespeare to convey both the violent and passionate tones of his play. Luhrman's adaptation of the play however is situated in modern day Verona beach which is said to be a variation of Venice beach. Verona beach appears to be a gloomy yet dramatic city accompanied by it’s run down amusement park on the beach and litter filled streets with a warm sun behind it all. All of these aspects of the settings helps to showcase the passion and violence of the play as the sketchiness …show more content…

Carlei's adaptation of the play has the same scene however does not uphold the gradual accumulation of the fight before it occurs. Everything is considered to be a bit sudden which omits from the climatic tone of the play. Unlike in Luhrman’s version where in contrast to both the original text and Carlei’s version the montagues start the brawl yet it is still able to sustain the dramatic and violent tone through the slow gradual escalation of the Montagues belittling the Capulets then them undergoing a fight with each other which can be contemplated as a more intense fight where they end up setting fire to the location they are at and one of the monatuge ends up injured by Tybalt. Compared to the 2013 adaption Lurhman’s version distinctively exhibits how violent the situation is between both the households. Whilst not being set during the same time period or location as the original play, it can be seen that the setting of Verona beach is still able to convey the passionate and violent tones that Shakespeare wished his play to

Get Access