The Puritan Justice System “But he that doeth wrong shall receive for the wrong which he hath done: and there is no respect of persons” (Col. 3:25). In seventeenth-century New England, the Puritans strongly believed in public punishment and judgment for all sins. In The Scarlet Letter, the punishment assigned to the people who break God’s law seems harsh; however, what was this punishment like in comparison with the acceptable punishment of that day?
In the 1600’s, the New England Puritans were strict enforcers of God’s law. Those who enforced the laws and those who interpreted the laws were often one and the same person. The religious rulers of that time often maintained an impossibly high standard with serious consequences for offenders.
…show more content…
“In June of 1645, the General Court passed an act that outlined the punishment for fornication. Every person who committed fornication ‘before or without lawfull contract’ was to be imprisoned for up to three days and either whipped or fined ten pounds” (Lauria). Although this seems harsh, this law actually revoked a previous law that allowed for execution of the guilty parties. In 1641, Mary Latham and James Britton both were convicted of adultery and were executed. Britton had contracted a serious disease which he felt was God’s judgment for his sin. Overwhelmed by his guilt and afraid of the further judgment of God, he confessed his and Mary’s sin to the magistrates. Initially, Mary denied the accusations; however, after she was tried and convicted she admitted to the deed and revealed the names of several other men with whom she had also been involved with. Both sodomy and “buggery” were also strictly forbidden. “In 1642, Edward Preston was sentenced to be publicly whipped at both Plymouth and Barnstable ‘for his lewd practices tending to sodomy with Edward Mitchell, and pressing John Keene thereunto (if he would have yielded)’” (Cox). A young man who was convicted of “buggery” - bestiality - was hung for his offense and all the animals put to death, just as the Bible …show more content…
When she meets an unearthly young minister, they are attracted to each other and eventually succumb to adultery. When Hester, the young lady, becomes pregnant she is charged with adultery. Her punishments include: public humiliation on the scaffolds, imprisonment, and wearing a scarlet “A” on the outside of her garments forever. A similar story that Hawthorne might have based his tale on was the story of Mary Bailey. Mary immigrated to Maine and married a local fisherman. After his unexpected death, she became a live-in housekeeper for an elderly minister. The Puritan townspeople, who hated this certain minister because of his “liberal” ways, accused the minister and Mary of living improperly together. Attempting to quell the rising accusations, the minister told the townspeople he and Mary married secretly. Mary continued in the minister’s house, but became involved with a neighbor. Their affair became public when she became pregnant with her neighbor’s child in 1651. Mary was sentenced to thirty-nine stripes, and six weeks after delivery, she was to be branded with an
Erikson explains that to most English people of the 16th century, Puritans became an annoying sect of rebels. Overbearing and unrelenting, many detested the exaggeration of conventional values that the Puritans displayed. Feeling restricted by the formalities of the Church, Puritans quickly became deviant in the eyes of society. By moving to Massachusetts Bay, Puritans hoped to create their own ideas of what is “right” and “wrong”, much like any community attempting to set boundaries. However, problems arose when laws were to be mandated in a Biblical sense. God could not sit at a pulpit in a courtroom, so then how would a strictly religious group maintain itself? As Erikson states, “one of the surest ways to confirm an identity, for communities as well as individuals, is to find some way of measuring what one is not”. From this, they developed a keen sense of Devil distinction – that is, ways in which the Devil presented himself through the behaviors of individuals.
Because the immigrants were extremely religious, they had formed a new church known as Puritan Christianity. In addition, the Puritans believed that there was no separation between the church and the justice system. One must follow the Ten Commandments strictly, or else they will be punished to the fullest extent of the law. The reverends or the judges, those who were responsible for resolving any legal matters, were said to be the ones pulling through with God’s will. Ultimately, the punishments brought upon the accused were extreme, as they were either publicly whipped, had their ears removed, or were ordered to be hanged.
It states, “I was hanged for living alone/ for having blue eyes and a sunburned skin,/ tattered skirts, few buttons,/ a weedy farm in my own name,/ and a surefire cure for warts” (lines 10-14). This passage demonstrates that the accused, typically, were considered abnormal by society. Mary lived alone, had tattered skirts, few buttons, and a weedy farm. These were things that may Puritan households did not have. Furthermore, her treatment for warts may have been considered magic or witchcraft by Puritans. So, these characteristics of Mary may be considered odd to society. She was made a target for witchcraft allegations, because she was considered
the nature of punishment the Puritan’s would endure. In the first chapter, the Puritan lifestyle is
When the Puritan came to the New World after being rejected in England for their beliefs, they knew the demand of perfection in God’s eyes could never be fully accomplish. Humans could never live up to the standards that God set out. After settling in New England, the Puritan became well aware they needed to have law enforcement with religious obligations, and most importantly the sexual temptations. Knowing that human could never fully obey God’s word and always be tempted, the puritans enforced certain punishments for certain sexual crimes, including fornication, adultery, rape and buggery or sodomy.
Nathaniel Hawthorne portrays the ideology of Puritan society in the novel the Scarlet Letter; however reader also get to witness his characters being an illustration of hypocrisy and victims to their own guilt. In the Scarlet Letter, as in many of Hawthorne’s shorter works, he makes profuse use of the Puritan past: its odd exclusionary belief, its harsh code of ruling, its concern with sex and witchcraft. The Scarlet Letter is a story that is embellished but yet simple. Many readers may view this novel as a soap opera due to the way Hawthorne conveys this Puritan society’s sense of strictness and inability to express true emotion along with the secrecy and how deceiving the characters are being. As the story unfolds the main character Hester Prynne is bounded in marriage at an early age. She engages in an adulterous affair with an unknown member of their small village. Hester soon becomes pregnant and with her husband’s absence the chances of this child belonging to her husband are slim. The towns’ people know that she has committed a sin and imprisons her for her crime.
The Puritans designed a theocracy with their government enforcing God’s laws. The Enlarged Salem Covenant of 1636 states the Puritans “will willingly do nothing to the offence of the church” while obeying their rulers in the Bible Commonwealth (Document C). Governor John Winthrop called the Massachusetts Bay Colony “as a city upon a hill.” With “the eies [eyes] of all people” set upon them, the Puritans were to be a model
The setting took place at the time when the English immigrated to North America with the belief that the English church was not strict enough. Because the immigrants were extremely religious, they had formed a new church known as Puritan Christianity. In addition, the Puritans believed that there was no separation between the church and the justice system. One must follow the Ten Commandments strictly, or else they will be punished to the fullest extent of the law. The reverends or the judges, those who were responsible for resolving any legal matters, were said to be the ones pulling through God’s will. Ultimately, the punishments brought upon the accused were extreme, as they were either publicly whipped, had their ears removed, or were ordered to be hanged.
Religion was a huge part of law, the court, and the state in Puritan New England. The Puritan church was mixed with the state and often they seemed to almost combine. Laws were a combination of the state and religion (Yale 9). Referring to church and state, David Yale wrote, “The distinction
The article begins by stating that the puritans came to America to set a model for the Anglican Church. In order to accomplish this, the puritans had to have many laws that were supposed to be met with harsh punishment. Among these laws were many
The 17th century Puritans were known to represent a religious group migrating from England to America in order to practice religious freedom. These groups were determined to “purify” churches of England from Catholic practices. Puritans are known for their religious, social, and political influences on early America. Edmund S. Morgan’s novel The Puritan Family highlights a part of history that many would tend to look over upon- that is, the complex structural life of Puritan Families in the 17th century.
While living with the Captain and his wife, Mary faced a lot of physical abuse.
The Puritans goal in New England was to create the perfect pure society where nobody sinned and God ruled completely. They attempted this by making laws about and regulating every aspect of life in the colony. To achieve this, the church needed to rule the colony. And if the church ruled the colony, only the real Puritans could be part of the church. They believed only a minority of the population pure enough to be a part of the church. In reality very few people were ever able to give enough evidence that they had completed their part. As a result, two-thirds of the population failed to qualify as church members. The Puritans enacted many laws to keep the non-Puritans living religious lives. They created an official whose only job was to check up on ten families daily to see if anything out of the ordinary was happening and to make sure everyone who was able went to church. Their idea was that everybody, even if they weren’t part of the church, should be very religious. Therefore they created their laws with principles based on the Old Testament. They dreamed of a society where everybody followed the laws and lived a peaceful, god-fearing existence. To make this dream realizable, the Puritans created severe penalties for breaking the laws. These ranged from whipping and being thrown in the stocks for minor offenses, to banishment and death by hanging for serious ones. To be a good Puritan one had to work hard all
Puritans may have tried to give themselves the appearance of a perfect society, but it was really just as corrupt and full of sinners as any society today. In the Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, The Crucible by Arthur Miller and “To My Dear and Loving Husband” by Anne Bradstreet, there is evidence for this. In Puritan literature, although they try to hide it, sin is very common, in that Puritans do the opposite of what they preach, but still harshly punish those who sin.
It is difficult to draw parallels between the staunch beliefs of Puritan society in colonial America and the freedom experienced in the country today. The Puritans lived strict lives based on a literal interpretation in the Bible, and constantly emphasized a fear of God and a fear of sin. Modern society looks at this negative view of humanity as a whole as an out-dated opinion from the past, believing that, "Now people know better than that." However, faults in human nature can not be completely erased by the passing of time and the modernization of society. People still have emotions of love, compassion, envy, and pride; and many types of interpersonal relationships within their community. Puritan literature