Seventh Man Essay “Objective guilt is when the guilt is fitting to one’s action: guilt is appropriate because one acted to deliberately harm someone, or could have prevented harm and did not”. The Seventh man is a story about a man who is in a support group telling a story about his friend K. he lost in large wave and years after the accident still feels guilty. Some people may believe after reading the fictional story that the Seventh Man should not feel guilty that he did everything he could to save K. I think differently than those people and believe that you should feel guilty. I believe that the Seventh Man could have done more to save his friend K. from being drowning and should not forgive himself. The Seventh Man should not forgive himself for what happened to his friend K. because he could have done more. Not only could the seventh man have done more, but he even basically said that he could have done more. In the story at one point it says, “I told myself to run over to K., grab hold of him, and get out of there”, then at another part …show more content…
However, I believe that my views on the situation are the correct ones. For starters, I had said about how Spinoza wrote about things going unexpectedly wrong, but even though things went wrong the Seventh Man still could have run over and grabbed his friend K. In a previous paragraph I had said about how K. found himself running in the opposite direction away from K., this is another piece of evidence that shows that the Seventh Man could have saved his friend K. The other side believes he is innocent because he had nothing to do with the wave and did not physically harm K. However, he knew the wave was coming from previous signs, he knew K. could not hear him, and he knew he had time to run over and grab K. to keep him from being submerged by the wave. The Seventh man easily could have saved his friend K. from being engulfed by the
This switches the blame yet again from him to K. since the seventh man warned his friend before they went to the beach, and then he warned his friend again at the beach right before the incident. Which could have saved his life if he was as alert as he should of
Imagine you're in a life or death situation and you have only moments to spare before you will be swept out into the vast sea. This is exactly what the narrator of the story, “The Seventh Man” had to experience but instead of just his life being in danger he had a friend also who was swept away after 3 gigantic waves crashed onto the beach. Although, after this horrible disaster he blamed himself and felt it was all his fault his friend had been killed. This man should forgive himself because none of us know what the future holds.
Due to a prompt in our literature book, I have pondered this for a short minute or two; should the narrator of “The Seventh Man” forgive himself for his failure to save K.? Of course he should. Sometimes, holding grudges isn’t healthy, this occurrence being one of those instances. Besides, the narrator was going with his gut, even though the narrator seemed to think differently from this gut feeling. Let me expand on these claims.
The Fall by Colleen Nelson: The effects of guilt after a friend’s death When physic defenses move in to deny, repress, and ultimately suppress any awareness of shame, it usually shows that one is experiencing guilt. In the novel, The Fall, Colleen Nelson elaborates on the effects of guilt that the main characters Taz, Cory, and Ben face, due to the unfortunate death of their friend. Throughout the novel, Colleen demonstrates how people can feel guilty after their friend’s death through its negative effects such as depression and conflicts in relationships. To begin, depression is a clear effect of guilt.
Imagine there was a car accident, saw that the car was about to go up in flames, and it was right next to a gas station. You see that there was someone still in the car and was going to help them until you saw the enviroment you were now in. Would you risk your life to try to save the person in the car that could result in both of your lives being lost, or getting away from the gas station before the car went up in flames? Same type of situation with the Seventh man and K, if he were to save k he would be lost out at sea too.
People who end up in life or death situations should not feel obligated to the guilt that people think that they do not have. People should not feel guilt in places where they could have done nothing about it, and in situations where they could have done something; they should not be thinking of the what ifs and what could have been dones.
Guilt is an emotion that everyone experiences. Depending on what a person does, it can affect them in a way that could change them forever. In The Scarlet Letter, Nathaniel Hawthorne discusses how Hester and Dimmesdale had a baby together. Hester is already a married woman and Dimmesdale is a leader in the church. Hester has since been punished to wear a scarlet letter that shows her sin. This leads her to become guilty and Dimmesdale as well because he hasn’t admitted his sin. Hawthorne analyzes guilt and how Hester has a different outcome when she admits it than Dimmesdale who doesn’t. Some outcomes are better than the other and it’s not always in the way that one expects.
Additionally, through its narrator and the narrator’s best friend K., “The Seventh Man” clearly shows a life-or-death situation in the case of a typhoon in Japan. When in the eye of the storm, the narrator, who was a young child at the time, decided to take the risk to visit the nearby beach. K. decided to follow him. After calmly watching the beach, the narrator heard an extremely deep and loud rumbling coming from the earth. K., however, did not seem to hear the sound. Following his instincts, the narrator left K. to find safety behind a nearby dike. When the narrator called to K., he did not respond. An enormous
Argumentative essay The narrator of “The Seventh man” should forgive himself for his failure of not saving k because, I believe that if he had tried to save k he would have died as well because it was not a very good situation to be saved from. Also It is not his fault that that had happened to him it could have happened to anyone there, they always say things happen for a reason. I think you should always think of the both ways it could go as in like if i save this person i would be a hero, but if i don't save him i will have the guilt of losing him but also there is a chance i could die trying.
Shaibi, Mohamed November 3, 2015 Period 3 Essay “Guilt is cancer. Guilt will confine you, torture you, destroy you as an artist. it’s a black wall. it’s a thief.”Job
Everyone makes mistakes, and nobody’s perfect. In the story The Seventh Man, The narrator has friend named K. A typhoon hits where they live and everyone has to get in their homes and take cover. They come into the eye of the storm and have a break from the roaring winds and enormous waves and amounts of rain. The narrator decides to adventure down to the beach to check out the aftermath of the first part of the storm. K joins the narrator and the two friends head down to the beach. As the boys are looking through all the debris the winds start to pick up again, the waves starts rolling in bigger and bigger. The narrator tries to warn K but it's too late. He was taken by the Sea. That wasn’t the narrator's fault, he should be able to forgive himself because everyone
Shame, blame, disrespect, betrayal, and the withholding of affection damage the roots from which love grows. Love can only survive these injuries if they are acknowledged, healed and rare.” Brené Brown
However, if he would have tried to run over to his friend K., the Seventh Man may not have been able to make it out alive which would result in two deaths that day. Plus, accidents happen and the Seventh Man wasn’t thinking straight at the moment of the tsunami. As said in the story “As clearly as I knew what I ought to be doing, I found myself running the other way.” -(Murakami, 138) This quote from the story obviously shows that the Seventh Man was in a trance and did what his body told him do, not his mind.
The seventh man was scared to go back to the beach where the typhoon had occurred. Though, once he went back to that same beach, he felt a whole lot better. He stopped having bad thought and nightmares all together, and
The seventh man should not forgive himself for not saving K. My point of view is supported by the consequences and actions of what he has done and, not done and by what he states in his story. For example, he said he had the time to go and save K. This means that he just stood in place as he watched his best friend in danger and get swallowed by the giant wave. Additionally, in his story, The seventh man says he knew and felt that the wave was close and coming. Although he may have been in major shock, he could have forced himself to run to his own childhood best friend to save him from the upcoming death. Then again, others may say that this is not the case