preview

Sexual Assault Victims: Equal Recognition In Society

Best Essays

Essay Question: ‘All victims of crime are afforded equal recognition in society. Critically discuss this statement in relation to a crime of your choice.’
A victim will only be treated with their rightful recognition if they fit into certain criteria based on societal expectations. If they do not conform to these norms their ability to be recognised fairly as a victim will be compromised. Throughout this essay it will be argued that victims of sexual assault are not provided equal recognition in society for a number of reasons due to a number of factors. The first factor being that the media influences society into thinking that some victims are ‘worthy’ whilst others are not, creating an ‘ideal victim’. The second factor which determines whether …show more content…

Typically, when society thinks of a sexual assault victim, they view a young, vulnerable female. Although the overwhelming majority of sexual assault victims are female (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2016), male sexual assault victims are vastly underrepresented in the media and society. This is due to the societal beliefs that males who have been sexually assaulted must be less masculine and weak (Choudhary, Gunzler, Tu, and Bossarte 2011). Fear of stigmatism has caused male sexual assault victims to not report crimes and therefore not be recognised. A study conducted by Mezey and King (1989) found that many male victims did not report their crimes for fear of stigmatism or being seen as ‘queer’ (Mezey and King 1989, p.208). This is furthered by evidence from another study that reported that on average only 12.9% of male victims aged 18 years and older reported their assault to authorities (Tjaden and Theoness, cited in Choudhary, Gunzler, Tu, and Bossarte 2011, p.539). This fear of stigmatism is common among heterosexual victims, as one victim reported “if you let it [sexual assault] happen you must be queer, if you're not a queer it can't have happened” (Mezey and King 1989, p.208). As a result, a majority of male sexual assault victims are not recognised by society and if they are, are heavily criticized and shamed. This causes …show more content…

Recognition can be received from two major parties: the media and the criminal justice system, both of which reflect societal views and values. Whilst the media portrays sexual assault victims as white, middle-class, vulnerable women, this is evidently not the case. This polarised view of what a ‘real’ victim is reflected onto society and in turn leads to structural racism, which can be seen in the study by Cossins (2003), which creates limitations for those victims who are from cultural minorities or considered social deviants. Gender also determines whether a victim receives recognition and is illustrated in the underreporting of male sexual assaults due to fear of stigmatism. Ultimately, whilst the media conveys a skewed vision of what an ‘ideal victim’ is, it can be argued that the criminal justice system is objective and unbiased, as seen in the case study by Larcombe (2002), and the only challenge victims face is that of being double victimised by the defence barrister. Therefore, although only a minority of victims receive public recognition by the media, the criminal justice system views each complainant of sexual assault as a victim, until proven

Get Access