preview

Should the Death Penalty Be Legal? Essay

Decent Essays

There is a lot of controversy about whether the death penalty should be legal or not. It is widely used, with only 18 out of the 50 states having abolished it, but should it be permitted, regardless of the popularity of it? The answer is no. It should be abolished because it demeans life, is cruel, prison is a better punishment, and it is not effective. Steve Earle once said “My objection to the death penalty is based on the idea that this is a democracy, and in a democracy the government is me, and if the government kills somebody then I'm killing somebody.” The death penalty demeans life. It makes life seem like something that can just be thrown away if you do something wrong, when in reality, it is something that should be carefully …show more content…

“There is no man so bad that he cannot be made good for something.” says Jean-Jacques Rousseau in his book, The Social Contract. Everyone can become a better person in some way or another. People make very bad decisions sometimes and there is nothing anyone can do to prevent that, but once this happens, then, we can work it out with the person so that they realize that what they did is wrong and that they can do so much better. If they are simply put to death, then there is no way for them to improve. Even if they live, and they do not improve in who they are, then we can all be calm in knowing that they had the opportunity to. “The death penalty is the number one killer of killers.” said Mokokoma Mokhonoana. A prisoner’s life consists of twenty-three hours per day in a tiny, empty concrete cell, with one hour of daily exercise in a small concrete swimming pool; they have no access to other inmates, and only rare contact with guards, who say nothing to them; they can see nothing of the outside world except a tiny sliver of sky. The death penalty as punishment is an unnecessary threat compared to the dullness of what prison life is like. Finally, the death penalty is not effective. If it really and truly worked, there would be no more crime deservant of the death penalty. All of it would have stopped when the death penalty was first legalized. If criminals feared death, they wouldn’t commit the crime in the first

Get Access