preview

Similarities Between Like Water For Chocolate And Pan's Labyrinth

Decent Essays

Max Amsterdam Ms. Havard Magical Realism Essay. While both Guillermo del Toro’s Pan’s Labyrinth and Laura Esquivel’s Like Water For Chocolate use magical realism to navigate harsh realities, the demonstration and function of magic differ significantly, reflecting distinct cultural and societal contexts. In Guillermo del Toro’s Pan’s Labyrinth, the protagonist Ofelia’s encounters with magical creatures and tasks in a fantastical world offer a clear contrast to the harsh backdrop of post-Civil War Spain. The incorporation of magical realism into the story serves as a device to exhibit the psychological and emotional struggles of people living in an oppressive society. “things out here aren't too good”. And soon you'll have to come out. Mom …show more content…

The protagonist, Tita, possesses supernatural abilities tied to her emotions, which have a big effect on the lives of those around her. “Her body was giving off so much heat that the wooden walls began to split and burst into flame.”(54). After consuming the quail in rose petal sauce, Gurtrudis couldn't help but feel this sexual, hot desire for all things around her. Eating the meal Tita served, caused her body to heat up to the point where it started a fire. Esquivel’s use of magical realism reflects the rich cultural heritage of Mexico, where fantasy and tradition are deeply intertwined with everyday life. After the passing of Nacha, Tita was nervous that the responsibility of cooking for the ranch fell on her, that she didn't know if she could carry on the lineage of chefs.” Tita was the last link in a chain of cooks who had been passing culinary secrets from generation to generation since ancient times.”(48). Through the lens of magical realism, Esquivel explores the many details of Mexican culture, including its cooking and superstitions. The magical elements, such as Tita’s ability to infuse her cooking with her emotions, serve as a deeper purpose, expressing how the power of love has a connection to food, emotion, and identity in Mexican society. Additionally, the use of magical realism allows Esquivel to challenge gender …show more content…

In “Pan’s Labyrinth”, the magic serves as a form of resistance against oppression, mirroring the historical struggle of the Spanish people during the Franco rule. The fantastical elements provide a means of exploring the trauma and resilience of people living under authoritarian rule, which furthermore provides the audience with a look at how there is a human capacity for both cruelty and compassion. “You are Princess Moanna, daughter of the King of the Underworld.” When everything turned for the worse in her life, hearing this gave her hope to fulfill the mission the Faun set her on. In contrast, the magic in “Like Water for Chocolate” is deeply rooted in Mexican folklore and traditions, reflecting the rich cultural heritage of the country. “For her it would have been childs play to crack those thousand nuts.”(230). Cooking became the root of Tita's most joyous memories. Separating cooking from Tita is like taking away everything that makes Tita who she is. Esquivel’s use of magical realism celebrates the vibrancy and importance of Mexican culture, while also providing a lens through which to explore themes of love, longing, and

Get Access