Leslie Feinberg’s Stone Butch Blues discusses the reality that a person’s identity is not based solely on singular moments in one’s life but on all of those moments added together. Sexuality and gender are in a constant state of flux, able to change from moment to moment, and the person experiences them in moments. Mimi Marinucci uses Gender Defined and Undefined to discuss this very experience, and I question if sexuality and gender can really exist, if by the moment they are constantly changing and fluid. I think that Stone Butch Blues demonstrates that the very nature of gender and sexuality is changing, and that moments - or states of being - do not have essential definitions but are no less valid for that characteristic; further, over …show more content…
At the beginning of the novel, Jess talks about what it was like to be young and already posing questions about identity and then through the novel explores that identity. Jess feels as though, from the moment she was born, that she was different from other typical girls, forcing her to question herself. Over time, she joined in with the butch scene, taking on a masculine female persona, and then eventually taking hormones to become physically male; however, she stopped hormones when she realized they were not for her and did not accurately fit into her identifying characteristics. One could argue that Jess is confused throughout this novel, struggling to find that piece of herself that fits just right and is constantly switching out pieces to do so. However, I think that what Leslie Feinberg is portraying is not a lost and confused individual, but an individual who changes. Jess’s identities throughout the book - from Butch to man to woman to Jess - are not each of themselves incorrect. They are real and valid at the time that they exist. Jess’s change over time, from where she starts to where she ends up, is what defines her as a person, not the labels that tried to give her an unchanging definition over time (Feinberg 322, …show more content…
Our standards of acceptable deviant behavior over time has changed, seemingly in some abstractly exponential way, but the pattern over time has not really been consistent (Shilts 1-30, Pew). To be clear, society relates to the human context in general, not just a specific region or country. Without subdividing into groups, like Marinucci described, views on sexuality and gender are not wholly consistent (Marinucci 68). In the United States queer people are finding more openness, relative to recent history, but in many European countries queer people are more widely accepted and have been so for longer (Pew). Indonesia has five different, recognized genders, but a lot of the world has a very strict binary (O’Connor). This is not meant to talk about the dichotomy between East and West, or everywhere else and the United States, but more so to make the point that, as far as human sexuality and gender are concerned in the general human context, gender and sexuality do not seem to have clear patterns of change and evolution so as to form an actual definition for them. Questions like, What does it mean to be a woman? or What does it mean to be queer? have different answers depending on where the question is asked. Even the lexical terms used to talk about those identities changes depending on geography (O’Connor). Those identities
She says that although she is only fourteen, and still considered a child, she feels as more of a person than a kid. We can see that she makes her own decisions and thinks her own thoughts because she knows the difference between right and wrong. This makes up a big chunk of her identity alone because she is forming her own sense of morals, which highly contribute to the actions she makes and the person she is.
Ideas about sex, gender and homosexuality have been changing rapidly over the past several decades in the United States. There are several obvious reasons for this. The primary one is legal: various legal decisions by the United States Supreme Court have altered existing law on the subject of sex and homosexuality, and substantially affected matters of gender as expressed in law. But there has also been a social shift driven by medicine, largely based on response to the AIDS epidemic at its height in the 1980s and 1990s, but also in terms of other medical matters such as contraception and abortion.
Through out her book she continues to raise questions to make you think such as: “What does it mean to be a man?” and “What does it mean to be a woman?” In her circumstance she is a male to female transsexual who is also a lesbian, whose girlfriend actually ended up transitioning from female to male. And she raises the question, “What does all of this mean?” she also talks about those who define themselves as neither gender (Bornstein). Through her book she strives to make readers think about their life and the people around them. The overall questions she asks are: “What is Identity?” and “What is your identity?” She uses personal experience, stories, theories, political activist, television shows, and humor to back up her theories and arguments while continually raising questions about gender, orientation, desire, and why we as a society are so attached to a dualistic gender system. She does a great job of achieving her goal in teaching readers about the basics of the topic while making readers think.
In essence, Janie had a hard time finding her identity but she never gave up, she was willing to go on and find out who she is. Throughout Janie’s childhood, her marriage to Logan, Joe, and then finally Tea Cake she struggled with finding her true self. Janie has always hoped to have an identity independent of anyone else but never really knew how to achieve this goal until she finally left Tea Cake. Janie to me is a model for women who wish to behold their own freedom, identity, and a sense of self. Overall Janie's true identity is one that many women like myself wish to maintain because of her strong willpower and self confidence that no one in her time period would usually have.
Gender norms surround every person in every culture, even though they have variety in each culture, they are still real and still impact individuals who stand out from the norms. Leslie Feinberg's book “Stone Butch Blues” shows how hard it is to challenge gender in the 1960’s when homosexuality and the transgender movement was something that was just starting up. Leslie shows the reader that just by existing in a transphobic environment ze is challenging what it means to be a man or a woman, and more importantly, what’s in between. Leslie shows that gender isn’t just black and white, it’s a spectrum of colours.
Everyone goes through changes in life, especially ones that define who you are. In David Kaplan’s short story “Doe Season,” he portrays a young tomboyish girl that metamorphosis into a young woman over a short hunting trip. Not only does the young girl enjoy spending time with her father, but she enjoys the things that he does – shooting, camping, hunting. This is not typical of your average girl, or even a 9-year-old girl. Throughout the story there are symbols that show the audience Andy’s conflicts with herself and her gender or sexuality. It is also clear that she struggles with herself and her gender role in society.
Leslie Feinberg’s “Stone Butch Blues,” narrates protagonist, Jess Goldberg, through hirs bodily transformation as a transgender. Jess, born as a woman, went from identifying as a “he/she” to passing as a man, until ultimately identifying as neither male nor female. Jess’s journey as a trans was far from easy, due to the violence, from the police and peers, ze often fell victim to. Moreover, when growing up Jess never felt as if there was a place for hir in society. When Jess was around 16 years old, ze finally begins to search immensely for hirs “type of people.” Through the referral of a co-worker Jess was able to find a bar, Tifka’s, which possibly contained hirs “type of people.” Once inside the bar Jess describes it as “everything [ze]
However society 's perspective on sexual identity has changed tremendously over the years. It used to almost be a disease that no one wanted to admit to having or have to deal with because that 's not what society viewed as “normal”. It was even said that only homosexuals can contract HIV/AIDS. In some cities, people got attacked physically because of the disagreement on homosexuality. Homosexual denied it their homosexuality because they didn 't want to be judged, but more and more people are admitting to it. Historical perspectives have changed too, especially in the U.S military service when homosexuals were banned from serving until 1993 when the “Don’t Ask Don’t Tell” policy was passed which allowed homosexual to serve in the military but not admit to it if they were asked. After World War II gay life flourished in urban areas such as Greenwich village and Harlem.
Things that have changed in the book over time included how J's mother got used to referring to J as a "him" after maybe five to six months which made J feel much more better knowing that his mother is much more accepting of "his" decision about who he wants to be. Although his dad is still slowly getting used to seeing and hearing about his old, new "son". Now that he's been taking testosterone for a while it's been easier for people to refer to him as a guy and use "his" and not "hers" anymore, which is a relief when he goes out in public. I think that in the beginning of the story J just told his parent that he is transgender out of the blue. His parents weren't really sure about what that meant so they were scared or stressed out and didn't want there little baby girl to change. But now that they have a little picture about what that means to be transgender after a few months it sunk in and they now know how testosterone works and what it really means to be transgender. It did take a few months but it did end up sinking in and now Carolina and if he's lucky Manny will try there best to keep an open mind about it and still love their little baby "boy" no matter what happens. In a result
(Cisneros, 105), Lucy feels trapped by her background and claims: “….I understood finding the place you are born in an unbearable prison and wanting something completely different from what you are familiar with, knowing it represents a haven.” (Kincaid, 95) In both cases, the characters are not very pleased with what they were born with and with the background that they have, hence seeking change; but they also recognize that their identity is not something they can escape from how hard they try. Of course, they can change their lifestyle and the way they present themselves to others, but they cannot change who they truly are. They are reminded of this reality by the people around
She is a very successful businesswoman who holds her own without a man. However, she is willing to give up her independence to live a more practical and domestic lifestyle if she is married to Jeff. Jeff is clearly opposed to a relationship that involves a more independent and outspoken woman, who is not afraid to support herself. This contrast also shows the gender dynamic through the different careers of Jeff and
Alison does not want to hide her identity like her father, and made it a point to be open about her identity. Alison carries more masculine traits while Bruce is more feminine. Bruce tries to prevent Alison from showing her masculinity, creating tension and what Alison calls, “a war of cross purposes” (98). Alison wants to wear men’s clothing, experiment with cross-dressing in high school, and “be a boy” (221), but Bruce enforces her to wear feminine clothes and barrettes.
Gender and sexuality can be comprehended through social science. Social science is “the study of human society and of individual relationships in and to society” (free dictionary, 2009). The study of social science deals with different aspects of society such as politics, economics, and the social aspects of society. Gender identity is closely interlinked with social science as it is based on an identity of an individual in the society. Sexuality is “the condition of being characterized and distinguished by sex” (free dictionary, 2009). There are different gender identities such as male, female, gay, lesbian, transgender, and bisexual that exists all around the world. There is inequality in gender identities and dominance of a male
Throughout many countries around the world, homosexuality has always been subjected as a controversial matter. The societal attitudes towards the behavior of homosexuality vary substantially across Asia. Surprisingly, there are two conflicting attitudes toward homosexuality. Some Asian countries strongly condemn against homosexuality, whereas some Asian countries visibly accept homosexuality. Judith Butler explained that gender is represented as a stylized repetition of acts or imitation. She described the categories of sexuality and gender as a form of performativity (Butler 1996, 368). This essay will focus on China and South Korea and explore the experience of gender identity via to the socio-cultural contexts. This essay will also look
Each person in society experiences their gender and sexual orientation differently, as well as experiencing other people’s gender and sexual orientation. Redefining Realness tells the story and journey, of a trans woman, who ventures through life to finding her inner self. This biography not only delves into a personal story, but also bits and pieces of experiences people of the trans community may have in common in their own personal journeys.