preview

Subverting the Conventional: Combining Genre in Kelly's Donnie Darko

Better Essays

Subverting the Conventional: Combining Genre in Kelly's Donnie Darko

While planning an evening at the cinema, individuals do not discuss the specific guidelines of genre while deciding the film of choice. A reason for seeing a Western is never because the genre has evolved from primarily racist films involving cowboys and Indians to movies that vindicate Indians and work toward demythologizing the old West. Similarly, broad generalizations of genre are constantly used to categorize film. Courtship-Romance Musicals or Rock Operas are often shuffled into the generic class of Musical, while the 1930’s films of Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers, examples of Courtship-Romance Musicals, are in contrast to such films as Tommy or Jesus Christ …show more content…

Leo Braudy and Marshall Cohen explore the principles of genre in their book Film Theory and Criticism. Braudy and Cohen write that the most common criticism is that, ”Genre art… can never reach the heights of greatness because its creators are too tied to artistic precedents and are therefore not ‘original’”(607). Restrictions of genre destroy the individual artist or what is known as the “auteur” in film. Creativity and uniqueness is sacrificed for conformity in narrative, production, and societal issues. According to this criticism, genre films cannot be considered works of art and directors are not artists, but mere pawns of the studio system.

Another concern of theorists is how to precisely categorize genre when it is continually evolving. Braudy and Cohen write that, “The generic approach to art [genre] has frequently been attacked, however, for its terms are often imprecise and its methods of categorization unclear”(607). Presently, the most accepted form of categorizing genre is between fictional narratives, such as Gangster films or War films. However, there are other possible ways of labeling movies including physical properties (silent, color) or purpose and effect (comic, educational). Further problems arise when attempting to distinguish characteristics between genres of fictional narratives. What are the specific differences between an Anarchic Comedy and a Black Comedy? There are characteristics that can be found

Get Access