preview

Summary Of Man Up By Brian Phillips

Decent Essays

“I am here to start a fight, because I’m a man and that’s how I solve problems” (Phillips). The main argument presented in Brian Phillips’s essay “Man Up” is what ‘being a man’ means in football culture. Being a man is being tough, standing up for yourself, and not being afraid to fight back physically. In the NFL, football is a man’s sport where emotional/mental issues are a sign of weakness. Throughout his essay, Phillips criticizes the culture of the NFL (National Football League) by describing the scandal that took place between two football players: Richie Incognito and Jonathan Martin.
Since Phillip’s argument is about the negative culture of football, it is necessary that he establishes his role as a fan of the NFL. Being a fan of the NFL for years has allowed Phillips to understand the game more clearly. Phillips reads the tweets and watches the games, which makes him aware of anything that happens in the NFL, both on and off …show more content…

However, Phillips’s essay focuses more on the negative aspects of football and does contain some logical fallacies. The one main logical fallacy in this essay is overgeneralization. Phillips’ essay briefly over generalizes the attitudes of football players. In his essay, Phillips talks about the abusive actions of Incognito and describes how all football players are similar to Incognito. He categorizes all football players as being physical and tough, and not being afraid to fight. Phillips seems to say that all football players are the same and none of them have regards for emotional issues. Phillips states how he is a fan of football and how much he loves the game. However, he speaks negatively towards the actions of the players. Not all football players are like Incognito. This overgeneralization negatively affects Phillips essay because many football players and diehard fans may find this

Get Access