preview

Summary Of Mexican New York: Transnational Lives Of New Immigrants

Better Essays

Mexican New York: Transnational Lives of New Immigrants (Book Review)
Robert Courtney Smith (Ph.D., Columbia), the author of Mexican New York: Transnational Lives of New Immigrants, is a Professor of Sociology, Immigration Studies and Public Affair at the School of Public Affairs at Baruch College and the Graduate Center at the City University of New York (CUNY). Smith many specializations include Ethnography, Globalization, Ethnicity, and Migration. His foremost book, Mexican New York: Transnational Lives of New Immigrants won a Presidential award from CUNY and the American Sociological Association in 2008 as the overall Distinguished Book as well as many other prizes. His purpose in writing this book was to analyze “local-level” transnationalism …show more content…

Smith explores the different expectations and gender negotiation between immigrant. Different from the general perception, Mexican man do not experience the failed machismo crisis, neither does a women jump into the perceived feminism freedom found in the US. Rather, there is a negotiation on the gender ideology. A difference can be noticed in the second generation, however. The woman tends to grow with the similar gender ideology found in the USA while the man tries to gain the same masculinity their parents experienced back in Mexico. In fact, as Smith showed through Toño and Julia example, returnee have to renegotiate their gender roles. For example, Julia tries to embrace her Mexican culture while preserving her own autonomy. Overall, Smith’s analyses show that regardless of the gender ideology, immigrant cope with gender roles in New York very …show more content…

Although his research is not fully based in the Mexican immigrants, it is rather based in a small community of immigrants from Tucuani, this is a work that helps people to understand the transnational life of migrants in general. In fact, being an international student and coming from a country market by immigration, this book also provides an explanation of some for some of my personal experience. For example, when he notices how the first generation and second generation is treated differently when returning home. The first generation is well received and praised when the second generation is treated as arrogant. My country was also greatly impacted by civil war which forced a number of people to immigrate. This book analysis presented several explanations for the reason why first generation keeps the image of their country of origin as “home” that they would always come back and the second not so much. Like Julia, many second generation returning to my country feel happy to return home, but they make people unhappy since they would not let go of the values they learned growing up in a foreign country. I didn’t understand much and I confess that before moving to the US I also consider many of them arrogant. In fact, these views may influence how both generations are treated when returning to their home

Get Access