preview

Superiority Complex In The Penelopiad

Decent Essays

The Superiority Complex of Atwood’s Penelope Unlike many versions of Helen of Troy, in The Penelopiad Margaret Atwood paints the infamous woman as a siren, a goddess, and a murderer. By making the reader see Helen’s imperfections through Penelope’s eyes, new layers are added to this character so often explored in literature. Helen and Penelope’s dynamic relationship adds a layer to not only The Penelopiad, but also to the male-dominated Odyssey. These factors create a dynamic feminine force that informs both characters: without each other, they would not be as interesting as they are. Many of Penelope’s insecurities come from her own self-reflection, self-image, and experiences. At the very beginning of the novel she says, …show more content…

This fear takes up immense space in her mind, triggered first in the novel when Odysseus reminds Penelope that Helen has not yet given birth to a son (Pg. 64, The Penelopiad). This fear is fueled by stories from bards about Odysseus sneaking into Troy to speak to Helen during the war, and dreams of Odysseus and Helen sleeping together. She even fantasizes about Odysseus telling her that she is “worth a thousand Helens” (Pg. 89, The Penelopiad). This fear is partially justified; it has already been shown countless times that Helen has the power to seduce any man she chooses. However Penelope takes this fear to an obsessive point, letting her jealousy affect her interactions with Telemachus. When he returns from Menelaus’s house, Penelope’s questions quickly shift towards Helen, and when Telemachus replies that she was “As Radiant as Goddess Aphrodite” (Pg. 132), Penelope’s disbelief comes from her own insecurities about her age, forcing Telemachus into lies. Even though Penelope doesn’t believe the lies, she accepts them to sooth her own …show more content…

Even Odysseus seems to always go back to her “…why was he still—and possibly always—thinking about Helen?” (Pg. 64, The Penelopiad). Helen weaves her way in and out of the text as she does with people’s lives: effortlessly and without worry for her implications. She is a constant issue for Penelope, making her feelings for Helen range from admiration to loathing. Penelope simultaneously wants to be Helen and could not imagine ever being her, creating a tension that looms over the main plot of the novel. The two women have opposite power dynamics, and opposite mentalities on how to present themselves. Even though Penelope became the image of the perfect, wholesome wife in her death, she still value’s Helen’s whirlwind life, leaving Helen to be seen as either the mono-maniacal response Penelope has to her isolation and insecurities, or a challenge and other side to her own character and

Get Access