preview

Sympathy And Justice In The Children's Hour

Decent Essays

At first, The Children’s Hour seeming indicates to the audience a conclusion that it is troubled by questions of sympathy and justice. Conversely, the film portrays the cruel injustice inflicted by society on two guiltless women, Karen Wright, and Martha Dobie; mistakenly suspected of unnatural sexual behavior. In analyzing the results of Mary Tilford's accusations is a sad; but an accurate portrayal of how ignorance can ruin lives. Mary’s grandmother, Mrs. Tilford, searches for a delicate manner to suggest what she believes about Karen and Martha to her nephew Joe. Before she rationalizes her feelings as to why he should not marry Karen; Martha and Karen confront Mrs. Tilford with a discovery from one of the girls’ mothers, accusing them of being lovers. Joe defends Martha and Karen, demanding that Mary faces them with her story. Nevertheless, Mrs. Tilford refuses to allow it, believing that Karen and Martha are the brazen liars. At first, Joe attempts to convince Karen to marry him immediately; and taking Martha with them. He admits that he does not want to go, but remains insistent that it is their only choice for a chance at happiness. After Martha leaves, Karen begs Joe to ask the question that she knows is upsetting him; whether he believes that the accusations are …show more content…

Tilford. The women are disheartened and undecided as to what they will do now. They have been shunned and excluded from the small town; as their reputations remain shattered. Martha recognizes that she had become a stranger to herself; and, Karen unexpectedly appreciates how meaningful the connection is between them. Martha and Karen can no longer have faith in the culture they were brought up believing was compassionate. Martha hangs herself; showing that the variance between her internal and external life is too enormous and can’t possibly be tied

Get Access