preview

The Asterick-Parallel

Decent Essays

In 2001, the International Congress on Medieval Studies at Western Michigan University in Kalamazoo allowed three sessions on Tolkien to be presented. That seminal event was the ‘nucleus’ from which this collection sprang. For forty years, editor Jane Chance, Professor Emerita in English at Rice University, has written and taught on medieval literature, medieval culture, medieval women and modern medievalism. She has authored or edited five critical studies of Tolkien’s work, as well as numerous scholarly articles. In her introduction, Chance notes that since Peter Jackson began filming The Lord of the Rings in 1999, “there has been a parallel rise in interest in his writings and books about his writings” (1). Additionally, the publication …show more content…

The first essay, by John William Houghton, cast a very interesting light on Tolkien’s creation myth. Houghton uses ‘asterisk’ in “Augustine in the cottage of lost play: the Ainulindalë as asterisk cosmogony” as Shippey used ‘asterisk-reality’ in his description of Tolkien’s creative process. Asterick-realities may be based on assumptions which are imaginative, but they must be internally cohesive. Houghton’s essay considers the Ainulindalë as a cohesive construction within Tolkien’s world which also “fits neatly amongst the real cosmogonies known to early medieval Europe” (171). He examines how Saint Augustine, writing at the turn of the fifth century, understood the Old Testament book of Genesis. Augustine was apparently a careful and meticulous student of the text, which Tolkien surely would have appreciated. Tolkien chose to clothe his creation in the language of music, but Houghton shows where the concepts beneath the imagery would fit easily into Augustine’s understanding of creation. This essay was most valuable to me on a few points about sub-creation and the role of Man in God’s

Get Access