preview

Essay The Benevolent Master

Better Essays

The Benevolent Master

I.

The black identity during the nineteenth century in America was one based on a position of inferiority. The inferiority of slaves to their masters was expressed in several different ways, but all were designed to secure a dependent relationship of the slave to the master. Masters often viewed their slaves as deserving of a moral or religious upbringing, and saw themselves as responsible for completing this task. Paternalism transformed the relationship of slave and master into one of child and parent. In such cases the slave may have been spared the abuse of a cruel master, but suffered no less subordination. A benevolent master created a comfortable environment for slaves, ultimately producing complacent, …show more content…

The two words, "simple" and "child," strip Tom of his adulthood. Essentially, Tom is incapable of independent thought, putting him in the dependent position as a victim who needs to be saved. There is no risk of Tom attempting an escape because he is not allowed to imagine a life beyond his present condition.

As the protagonist of Uncle Tom's Cabin, Stowe uses Tom to make a point not just about the inhumanity which Tom is a product of, but of the model Christian who is submissive. Stowe looks to the obedient slave to set an example of a model Christian. The passive, submissive slave has the same faith in his or her master as the good Christian should: thus, Tom proves to be both a good slave and a good Christian. It then becomes the responsibility of the master to raise his or her slaves as they would a child, instilling in them Christian virtues, which consequently stifles the desire to be free. This parallel is seen in a discussion between Eliza and her husband George, "Well,' said Eliza mournfully, 'I always thought that I must obey my master and mistress, or I couldn't be a good Christian." (16) Her husband agrees: in the case of a kind master it makes sense for a slave to obey. It is significant that George agrees with Eliza, it is his tyrannical master which prompts his escape. Recognizing the benefits of masters like the Shelbys makes George's agreement with Eliza

Get Access