preview

The Guns Of August By Barbara Tuchman

Decent Essays

In Barbara W. Tuchman’s book, The Guns of August, she argues that each competitor in World War I did some very feebleminded things in the first month of war. Tuchman quibbled that the first month was a disaster of headstrong generals, who were determined to stick with military plans that weren’t succeeding. The author explains that both sides lost in the first month because of foolish mistakes.
Tuchman presents three mistakes Germany made. The first mistake was that they used terror against the civilian population. If there was any sort of resistance in the town they took; the Germans would shoot at the invading soldiers, cut communication lines, sabotage roads, railways or bridges, and destroy the food supply. Then the Germans would line up people from the local villages and shoot many of them to make an example. The Belgian Minister once Germany started to invade their country said “If we are to be crushed let us be crushed gloriously.” This not only increased the will to resist in the Belgian people, but warned the whole world about the tactics of German warfare. …show more content…

France was so set on their plans to attack the Germans head on at Alsace and Lorraine that they didn’t see the Germans grow strong in a huge area of French northern territory where there was plenty of agriculture and manufacturing that they greatly disadvantaged themselves. Tuchman’s assessment of the Russians was: “They entered the war without confidence and remained in it without faith.” In that first month, the Russians were so disorganized and unprepared that they took too long to get seriously into the war to matter much. The Russians were harmed by the weakness of Minister of War, General Sukhomlinov who “...bragged about not having ‘… read a military manual for the last twenty-five years.’” President Wilson of the United States wanted to remain neutral in the war so that at the last minute the U.S. could join the Allies become the savior of the

Get Access