preview

The Hobbit: Comparing The Book And Movie

Decent Essays

The Hobbit movie is more effective and more expressive than the novel. The Hobbit, by J.R.R Tolkien and movie director Peter Jackson, is mainly about a man who normally stays inside his home and does not explore in the outside world. He does not face many difficult obstacles in life and does not have much courage. One day, Bilbo Baggins gets a message saying that he must go on a journey and go through distractions that he has never experienced throughout his life. His goal is to get through the journey alive and make sure that it is completed. Two major differences that Peter Jackson changed in the movie that are not the same in the book are when the dwarves try and save Bilbo from the trolls and when Gandalf comes and shows the sunlight to …show more content…

For example, “The dwarves had heard noises from a distance, and after waiting for some time for Bilbo to come back, or to hoot like an owl, they started off one by one to creep towards the light as quietly as they could” (Tolkien 38). The dwarves told Bilbo to hoot if he had trouble with whatever the light was and he didn’t make any noise so they sent the dwarves one by one to find Bilbo. The movie scene is more effective because in the film, they have a plan to go all at once and to fight the trolls to rescue Bilbo. In the novel, the dwarves do not have a plan and they just send one dwarf at a time to see what the light is and to see if they can find Bilbo. In the film, the dwarves all charge at once, attacking the trolls, but are beaten. But, Bilbo hear the trolls say that they cannot be seen by the sunlight or else they would turn into stone. So, Bilbo gets an idea of lying to the trolls, so they wouldn't eat the dwarves. This is the first sign of Bilbo’s character changing and becoming more courageous. Bilbo shows much courage in this scene and many people cannot express that and feel how much Bilbo is changing in the book. Bilbo faces the trolls by himself for a little while but he knew how to handle them in the …show more content…

“Don’t start the whole argument all over again… or it will take all night” (Tolkien 40). The trolls did not want to cook the dwarves all night because if the sunlight sees them, the trolls will be turn into stone and will die. This is also more effective because in the book, the author just has Gandalf mimic the voices of the trolls for them to continue to keep arguing until the sun rises. This is not very fascinating for the viewers of the movie. So, Jackson decided to spice things up a bit and make this part of the film more interesting and more effective throughout the movie. In the film, Gandalf uses his magical staff to show the light to the trolls while Bilbo distracts the trolls. In the novel, Gandalf is the main hero but in the film, Bilbo is the main hero. This part of the film shows where Bilbo is a big part of being the hero who saves the day. In the novel, everybody thanks Gandalf for saving them once again, but the dwarves should be thanking Bilbo because in the movie, Bilbo does pretty much all of the work for the trolls not to eat them. Bilbo distracts the trolls by telling them how to “properly” cook dwarf and saying that the dwarves are all infested with rodents and are sick. The movie is more effective and more expressive than the

Get Access