preview

The Lives Of Others ( 2006 ) And Barbara ( 2012 )

Decent Essays

Both The Lives of Others (2006) and Barbara (2012) present a version of life under the oppressive communist regime of East Germany. Despite the similarities, the films have fundamentally different messages to deliver. On the one hand, The Lives of Others is concerned with the system of state oppression as a whole, of course the focus is primarily on a few people’s struggle or interaction with the state, but throughout the film we are given glimpses of how a wide range people become disillusioned with the oppressive regime; similarly the film also shows how the system of oppression can falter if the people in the system undermine it. On the other hand, Barbara focuses primarily on how one person, the titular character Barbara, is negatively …show more content…

Wiesler is then told point blank that the point of the surveillance is to help minister Hempf “get rid of his rival.” This revelation prompts Wiesler to his first act of defiance in the film, as he questions this action and asks his superior if this is what they signed up for. Although it is a minor act of defiance, given how quiet and dutiful Wiesler is shown to be, directly questioning a course of action is a major change for him. Wiesler begins to become disgusted with the obvious abuse of the system by the minister Hempf and Grubitz (Wiesler’s direct superior) who cares for nothing but getting a promotion. This blossoms into further acts of defiance as Wiesler encourages Sieland to reject Hempf’s advances. And later on, Wiesler actively helps Dreyman avoid imprisonment by hiding the typewriter he used to write the article on East Germany’s suicide rate.
Alongside Wiesler, the viewer also sees how the actions of the state lead to the disillusionment of Dreyman. At the start of the film, Dreymand is considered to be above suspicion and one of the few East German writers not under surveillance or accused of being subversive. So right from the start, the viewer sees the similarities between Dreyman and Wiesler, they are both considered model citizens who can be trusted to not betray the state. Much like with Wiesler, Dreyman’s disillusionment with the

Get Access