preview

The Lovely Bones: Movie Analysis

Decent Essays

Lesson 5 Review Comparison Activity
For this assignment I chose to read the reviews on the motion picture “The Lovely Bones”. I have read the book, but wanted to see if the movie was worth watching. I found two reviews for this movie one from Opposing Viewpoints and the other from Roger Ebert’s Movie Blogs. Opposing Viewpoints I found on the school database that was given by my instructor and the Roger Ebert review I found on the internet. Both these reviews demonstrate a different take on the movie and explain further on what really stood out to them on the content of this movie. In conclusion, these reviews do have me convinced that the movie is well produced and is as good as or even better than the book. However, between the two reviews there was both similarities and differences. The similarities was the focus on the in between after-life, they both focused on describing how unique and unreal it seemed like with the scramble of earth and heavenly things. Their differences though was one review focused on the …show more content…

It is definitely formatted as a blog verses a scholarly review. Because of this it is very opinionated and does not have the same descriptive imagery as the scholarly review. One specific quote from Roger Ebert stated “ The Lovely Bones” is a deplorable film with this message: If you’re a 14-year-old girl who has been brutally raped and murdered by a serial killer, you have a lot to look forward to” (par 1). This quotation is a very bold opinion that is straight to the point and is a little morbid for my taste. However, this is appropriate for the review being a blog style. The voice that Greg Ebert is trying to express, is his opinion and what the movie translated to him. He does express the dramatics of the storyline and how from the beginning we know she was murdered and that the reveal of the murderer was very

Get Access