preview

The Minnow Book Report

Decent Essays

The minnow is one of the controversial book, in the book you will find mental illness, pedophilia, and many creepy staff. This book is written in the first person, a 14 year old girl who name’s tom lost her family in the flood. In this book, many unsuitable themes and language were used in the novel, such as paedophilic, actions which caused by mental illness, and swear words through out the book, Therefore, this book should not be read by high school students, as such un-educational novel can negatively impact the way of which the students think.

The character exploration reveals why this book is unsuitable for high school students. The protagonist is named Tom who survives a devastating flood which claimed the lives of her sister and parents. Having no family at all, Tom decides to live to an old guy named Bill, who somehow made Tom pregnant despite the fact that Tom is only a grade 9 student. After escaping Bill’s house, Tom came across with Jonah, who was willing to let Tom to live in his house. Being mentally ill, she speaks to the fish, talks to her baby as if the baby can think, act and talk, and talks to her imaginary father. In page9:” I’m throwing you back, Sarah, ’I say. ’you belong in the water now, and I belong here …show more content…

The plotline is scattered and difficult to follow from chapter to chapter. Memories from Tom’s childhood and her conversations with animals and ghosts are oddly added in with the rest of her narration. Tom as a character clearly does not have a firm grip on reality. There is no true resolution. Nothing involving Bill is clearly solved, and the novel ends just feeling incomplete. When studying a novel, not only the theme, and character, but also the plot of the book is important in order for students to understand. And with unrelated storylines of Tom’s past intersecting with real time events, it is very difficult to learn and understand the message of the

Get Access