In Zadie Smith’s article, “The North West London Blues,” she repeatedly stresses on the vitality of public libraries, building an argument, through which, she attempts to induce her readers that public libraries are important and should remain accessible. In pursuance of her goal, Smith resorts to the use of ethos, the appeal to ethics, pathos, the appeal to emotion, and logos, the appeal to logic, in addition to her unique use of diction, rhetorical devices, and subtle word choice.
The author starts off with a rhetorical question: “What kind of problem is a library?” urging the readers to think about this question as they continue to read the article. The question grabs the readers’ attention, and intrigues them to read on to find and answer. She further utilizes this technique of rhetorical questions throughout the article for the same purpose of emphasis on the vitality of the role of public libraries. Moreover, Smith extensively employs the use of metaphors and personification. For example, she describes the internet as libraries’ “universal death knell”, which portrays the internet’s negative impact on the development of
…show more content…
First off, she addresses the reader’s conscience, in attempt to to evoke them to take action, and to awaken their morality towards maintaining libraries. She also appeals to the readers’ emotions. When she repeatedly uses the word “friends”, and further assures her argument when she herself states that the matter is rather regarded by many to be emotional, and neither ethical, nor logical. She says, “Not logos or ethos but pathos.” Smith only resorts to logos in the very last paragraph when she says, “British libraries received over 300 million visits last year.” This might be the only piece of statistical evidence to be found over the course of the entire article. This proves the author’s endeavour to influence the readers’ emotions and morality, rather than their
For libraries to remain a place for a lively exchange of ideas, librarians should be armed with the right knowledge and strong conviction to preserve people’s rights.
Zadie Smith’s deft appeal to identity throughout the article begins with her discussion of libraries. Smith’s expresses, “We’re humans, not robots.” This is one way for the author to show that people are people and we feel things, while a robot wouldn’t feel an emotion. This is the author’s way of relating to the audience and showing that they have feelings and emotions as well. Smith is showing that the library has significance to her. Smith also shows her reader that she can relate to how they feel by stating, [Libraries] the only thing left on the… street that doesn’t want either your soul or your wallet.” Smith uses this to show how she understands the audience, and that she also has the same issues as the people who are reading the article.
Herring, Y Mark. “Are Libraries Obsolete? An Argument for Relevance in the Digital Age.” http://eds.b.ebscohost.com.northcenttexascollegelibrary.idm.oclc.org/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=81d1e5f8-4786-40ea-8f01-3d2f25c73c8a%40sessionmgr101&vid=1&hid=120. Herring was questioned by a legislature, “Everything was on the Internet, so why did our students need a new, big library building?”. "Not everything is on the Internet" answers Herring. In his most recent novel, Are Libraries Obsolete? A defense for libraries relevance in what has become a very digital age looks back at things he said in some of his earlier works. Herring makes it believed that the Internet is dangerous, and attempts to convince all readers of his works that sticking with libraries as their sources is “safer” than the alternative:
Another challenge of a community-led librarian is that they needn’t necessarily lbe professional librarians. (Stevenson & Domsy, 2016), Zimdars mentioned that oftentimes her role as outreach librarian looks more like a social worker (personal communication, October 10, 2017). Stevenson & Domsy also note “an ability to penetrate communities and work closely with vulnerable groups takes precedence over professional qualifications. This opens the door for the hiring of social workers and other professionals (or paraprofessionals) over librarians” (2016). As community needs change, the culture, roles, and skills of the librarian also changes. Several graduate students had expressed apprehension about the direction libraries are moving towards in the way of community engagement and outreach (Hawkins, October 7, 2017). This trend may deter certain
In Ray Bradbury’s fictional novel about the horrifying future, he discusses topics that, politically and socially, can relate to Judith Ortiz Cofer’s short story; The Paterson Public Library. These two pertain to each other because both Bradbury’s and Cofer’s characters are afraid of situations that involve books. Though they do compare in many ways, there are also differences between the stories.
This source was important because it allowed us to see what is ‘legally’ considered a bill of rights for a library. As this is from a national association for libraries, it can be inferred that our own library would have shared the same ideals. This was important for the usefulness of for the Strategic Plan as it allowed us to outline the rules that the library would have to follow and how it would likely deal with events in the library.
In Eleanor Roosevelt's speech, “What Libraries Mean to the Nation”, she talks about the importance of libraries in the United States. She talks about how useful libraries are in making a better education for the people. She does this by using logical appeal and in an anecdote.
The London Public Library is an organization spanning the city of London, delivering services from 16 physical locations. The core services of the library include reference, reader’s advisory and referral; collections and lending; technology services; programming and community outreach. The library is focused on literacy, learning, culture/leisure/recreation, information and community meeting place. The past few years have seen significant resources pegged towards fund raising strategies, resulting in other areas of the organization being neglected and
The author of this article Mrs. Denise Davis is the director of the Office for Research and Statistics of the American Library Association. This means that Mrs. Davis is able to access and is responsible for the reports mandatory for each library across America to turn in each fiscal year, these reports are used to determine what changes the libraries need to make to better serve the public. Given her credibility to write on such topics she then chooses a topic each year to write on to prepare libraries and librarians across the country for the upcoming years. In 2010 Mrs. Davis choose to write on eBooks and their increasing popularity throughout the American population as well as the difficulties libraries have encountered in the past fiscal year to compete with eBooks. Because this article is written in 2010 it shows just how long libraries have struggled with the topic of eBooks and can demonstrate the new policies that have been used by the libraries throughout the past four years. This information can help my research in showing how eBooks have affected the library's behavior, and consequently give me the statistics needed to show the effects of eBooks on the libraries throughout the recent years. Understanding this source is outdated other sources will also likely be used in my final project from the American Library Association websites of statistics of more recent years.
In response to the closed down of local libraries in London, writer Zadie Smith argues that libraries should remain open in her article "The North West London Blues". She effectively supports her argument using evidence that attacks the reader's rhetorical appeals of ethos, pathos, and logos.
As new technologies are rapidly introduced, people are able to find any information with the access of internet. This leads to people questioning the relevance of libraries and its true purpose. Public libraries cultivate the value of increased education and a social unity to advancing as a society.
In “The Land Where The Blues Began” you see the hardships of Mississippi’s people and the every day challenges they were forcefully put through. Beatings and killings weren’t scarce and the payment for work was low. Through these times though, they were able to make light of the situation. In the works of handmade instruments and words that fully defined their feelings, these people found solace and comfort in the Blues.
Libraries are storerooms for history book. Communities of diverse people use the library for research that prepare them for higher education. People should not have to worry about having money to pay for the service. For example, People goes to libraries to educate themselves. Both, people who cannot afford to pay for private tutoring, or those who just want to learn more about what is going on in the country. The article makes a claim that, “tax dollars could be spend on project that better service the community.” Is mind blowing, because what can
I find this to be extremely high and very interesting. I started to form new thoughts about the main purpose of the library. “Are we a computer resource that happens to offer books and movies?” The questions I
Need Thesis: The worth of public libraries in America extends far beyond the books they offer. Despite the value of these resources to struggling communities, libraries have seen a decline in both public usage and federal funding in recent years.