Examining the concept of “Acting White” Education Settings
Bryce A. Powers
University of Houston Downtown
What is Acting White?
Imagine, it is the first day of school, and you are the new student, in a new environment, and no one knows who you are or where you come from. You notice how everyone is in his or her separate cliques, the jocks are in one corner but you do not play any sports, the chess club is in the coroner while everyone else is in their own worlds. You wonder where to go, where you would fit in, with whom you will get along with. You want to fit in but you seem to have nothing in common with anyone so you begin to act out to gain attention. You want attention not only in the social circles, but you want attention in your classrooms as well. How can you achieve your goal of being noticed? After reading the article, “The Burden of Acting White”. The concept of acting white comes from the struggle of blacks being qualified as inferior their white counter parts. From trying to keep up in school but at the same time, letting your true colors be shown was almost contradictory to what was going on in the classroom (Thomas). In the African American community, many issues are causing the epidemic of Acting White. Not saying that acting white is an issue; but who is to say how we are acting is wrong? We all have our own identities and it is up to us to help students mold themselves into who they want to become in the world.
The fourth chapter of "Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria?”is about the identity development in adolescence. It is said that when black children are growing up, they engage in many of the white culture’s beliefs and values as it is all around them. It is not until a little later where they begin to recognize the impact of racism. This can happen around the early stages of adulthood. It might even happen around the junior high age. Gender also comes into play around this time as well. A black girl wouldn't be acknowledged for her beauty in a white setting as she is not in the society's standard for beautiful. Since the black girls aren’t considered beautiful, they begin to feel devalued. The black youth are beginning
Also, this article really puzzled me for the idea of how Crosley was so able to push aside her anger and see her privilege, that kind of person is hard to find and she was able to go to university and become educated and push past the stigma. But Crosley also goes on to talk about class and how when Mcintosh talks about race, she could often substitute it for the word class. “The idea that any ol' white person can find a publisher for a piece is most certainly a symptom of class privilege.” I felt this statement was true and resonated with me because no matter how hard you work some may never succeed. You need opportunity and many don't even get the chance. As an future educator, I feel that it is my job to try to help the students along and recognized the extra attention that is needed for some children. A Question I want to ask to ask myself is do I see my White
There has been many years of racial stereotypes and wanting to fit into a group. The essays that show this theme are Just Walk on By: Black Men and Public Space by Brent Staples, The Myth of the Latin Woman by Judith Ortiz Cofer, and Shooting an Elephant by George Orwell. Staples shows his audience the struggles he has gone through as a black male. Cofer shows her audience the stereotypes that surround Latin women. Orwell shows his audience the overwhelming desire of being accepted into a group of people. All three of these authors want to be accepted by the larger group of people. Society needs to empathise and be aware of the silence that surrounds these issues. Otherwise it can create depression amongst minority groups.
Once a person begins to realize that they are portrayed differently than others, their entire mind set changes. Black citizens decades ago had to deal with day in and day out feeling like
One of Beverly Tatum’s most popular works, Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria?, outlines racial identity development and shows us what it means to be Black in today’s society. Tatum uses reasonable examples of her experience both as a parent and as a college professor. She is able to get readers to think in ways that might not be comfortable but are necessary and compelling. Recognizing understanding and embracing
I believe Tatum answers the question “Why are all the Black kids sitting together in the cafeteria?” not only through her description of William Cross’s Black racial identity model, but through James Marcia’s four identity statuses and Rosabeth Moss Kanter’s A Tale of O. Tatum follows up the question through Marcia’s four stages that an individual undergoes to discover their identity: diffuse, foreclosed, moratorium, and achieved (Tatum 53). Marcia’s identity statuses can be seen in more detail through Cross’s Model. Cross’s Model begins with a person developing self-awareness of the world’s perception about themselves. Consequently, the individual comes in contact with the preencounter stage. Hence, their instinct is to assimilate by rejecting who they are and accepting what the majority sees as acceptable. At least one event may cause the person to enter the encounter stage, in which they become aware of racism and how it impacts their life.
The concept of acting white is a slanderous phrase that disapproving blacks cast on other blacks for adopting certain things that are stereotypically “white”. In majority of situations when you associate someone with acting black it is a negative thing vs someone acting white is a positive. Why is being trashy, ghetto, and having low standards associated with being black? But when talking properly, educated, and having high standards considered to be white? These behaviors that people do are subjective because any race or group can act a certain way it shouldn’t equate that someone is acting a specific race.
They responded using the burden of “acting white” which suggested that minority students do perform well in school; they take the risk of negative consequences by their same race and peers because of acting white. The “acting white” plays out in educational settings because minorities interact within a classroom setting receiving good grades and enjoying school. Also,
Paul Dunbar’s poem, “We Wear the Mask”, has made me ponder about society’s views and opinions over the years. Dunbar’s poem was written during a time where African-Americans were looked down upon. These individuals were treated inadequately, subjugated while being used as slaves, while white Americans acted like their opinion did not matter. After reading this poem, it was shocking to see how African Americans had to put on a “mask” or disguise to cover their emotions and appear mentally strong for surrounding people. After reading all of the stories and being involved in the class deliberations this semester, it truly has been a “eye opener” for me, or anyone else to see how rapidly humanity is to judge someone else, for the color of their
Why you act so white? You aint smart cuz you say big words! You always think you know everything. no matter what degree you get, you still black.
The education system is notorious for teaching its own agenda, and not necessarily all the facts of a situation. For many years, the education system on all levels has been teaching students what it means to have privilege, and how life would be if they did not. Usually, the white students are the subject of privilege, and the minority student are the subject of life with racism, and without privilege. White privilege has been an underlying lesson to students for generations, and contributes to the power and superiority white people feel over everyone else. When the Michael Brown shooting occurred, it opened up many people’s eyes to the inequalities that are being perpetrated by the very education system meant to teach students how to live
Blacks kids do not associate education as acting white, but see being educated and being able to speak properly as being white. In ‘You Talk White:’ Being Black and Articulate’, Keith Powell states in, “Being smart, black, young and American had become a liability. People seemed to think I was some kind of walking oxymoron. I was often asked to be more “urban and it never seemed like the right time or place to launch into a diatribe about how I was born in West
The next morning I called home. That fall I would start school at a Historically Black University, as systematically different as I could get from my southern Missouri predominantly white university. I flourished, I was involved in numerous organizations, inducted into a national Greek lettered organization and soon after, elected President of my chapter. I developed essential study habits and found my sense of belonging. If you were to ask me what color my crayon was then; it would be the alluring brown or the rich black crayon in the box. My crayon was as brown as the dirt in mother Africa, and as black as the chains the “white man” used to put me into slavery. Yet, I still had not found my true identity I had merely assimilated to the culture around me. It would not be until I stepped into the working world that my true colors would show.
Prior to beginning my readings on white racial identity, I did not pay much attention to my white race. If someone had asked me to describe my appearance I would have said short blond hair, blue eyes, average stature, etc. One of the last things I would have noted was the color of my skin. Growing up in overwhelmingly white communities, I never thought to use the color of my skin to differentiate myself from others. Over the course of this dialogue I have learned that my white racial identity is one of the most defining aspects of my appearance in this society. There is a certain level of privilege that I am afforded based solely on the color of my skin. According to Peggy McIntosh, “White privilege is like an invisible weightless
There are many phrases and terms that can be used to describe ones’ speech, achievement, and actions. Some of these terms can have a negative connotation. One negative descriptor of an African American’s actions is actin’ white. Actin’ white is a term that deems peer pressure that can potentially lead to the destruction of African American success in mainstream America.