The Security Frame Essay

An immigration debate is framed by a person’s perspective and how they want to perceive the idea of immigration, “frames create a boundary around the discussion, defining the problem, locating responsibility…” Framing is important in a debate because it cuts directly to the idea, an example can be “photography”. A photographer takes their photo in a way they want to see it, they crop people out, they edit it, or they just take the picture in a different angle. September 11 was not the cause of immigrants being known as lawbreakers and terrorists, even before that, immigrants were known as terrorists. September 11 was just “… the sacralized memory of the 9/11 attacks to reinforce the notion that a real American was a white American and to divide

In the article “The Framing of Immigration” the authors, George Lakoff and Sam Ferguson, claim that the United States of America has poor and inefficient discussions on immigration because when the nation frames immigration, this broad subject is inadequately simplified and therefore the debates and arguments are one sided and unfair. Lakoff and Ferguson further support this claim by using hard evidence to demonstrate that the nation is framing immigration by using the illegal frame, the security frame, and the economic frame.

The authors George Lakoff and Sam Ferguson in the article “The Framing of Immigration”, claim that the United States of America has poor and inefficient discussions on immigration because the nation takes this broad subject and wrongfully simplifies it by framing immigration. Lakoff and Ferguson support this claim by using hard evidence to demonstrate the nation is framing immigration by using the illegal frame, the security frame, and the economic frame.

The connotation of “illegal” immigration implies that a majority of immigrants enter the American border only to organize crime, yet a larger proportion of illegal aliens come to America solely with the intent to work. In reality, illegal immigrants demonstrate strong loyalty to America, placing importance in its function as a shelter and refuge from persecution (Gold 3). Thus, in contrast to the stereotypical portrait of illegal immigrants, the unauthorized population represents a responsible minority that demonstrates respect and compliance with American policies. According to the article,

Even more frequently, his use of “undocumented” immigrants rather than “illegal” immigrants. Simply by calling himself and others “undocumented,” it provides a positive impression for the reader. This is a stark contrast to news and society, both of which refer to them as “illegal” immigrants. Referring to

Most Americans today believe that illegal immigration is an issue that the country really doesn 't know how to handle, but is one of the most important to solve now. The reason this problem is so important is because everyone has an opinion for the sake of politics or just as their two cents. People of higher class and those buried in the poverty line have different reasons as to why this is an over-exaggerated issue or a serious toxin to the United States. The wealthy may argue that most illegal aliens bring in crime and poverty, while others claim that immigrants actively strive for the american dream and complete jobs that no one else wants to do. Whereas those under the poverty line state that illegal aliens steal jobs from the unfortunate citizens, are breaking the law by coming across borders or overstaying their visas and are terrorist threats, other underprivileged citizens want to provide equal opportunity and have no quarrels with immigrants. In other words, all citizens have diverse views on how to handle immigrants regarding the issues of law, economics and social issues.

The debate of illegal immigration in the United States is one that is plagued with many details, and one that sparks a huge amount of controversy among politicians and citizens alike. While it is an issue that many argue about, few people are actually knowledgeable about the subject and have facts to back up their opinions. According the Center for Immigration Studies, the “unauthorized resident immigrant population is defined by all foreign-born non-citizens who are not legal residents” (CIS). This definition incudes people who emigrate from countries all over the world; it is not exclusive to those who come from Mexico and surrounding Central and Southern American

The reforming of America?s immigration policy is something that can no longer be avoided and must be dealt with as soon as possible. Years of neglect by governmental agencies and policies makers have now made this issue one of the biggest in American politics. First of it must be understood that immigration does no only effect curtain areas of the country and curtain aspect of public life but rather all of American life. Both legal and illegal immigration affect major issues such as jobs availability for all citizens, wages, education in public schools system and in general, health care issues, and the homeland security.

Immigration issues have brought about extraordinary open deliberation amongst group individuals. Specifically administrators, government officials, vested parties, and social liberties activists have been vocal in voicing their worries. It is assessed that there are about ten to eleven million undocumented immigrants in the United States (Immigration Policy Center, 2010). Immigration issues emerge from concerns with respect to the deficient number of visas that are accessible to bring both high and less skillful laborers in the nation lawfully to meet the changing needs of the nation's economy and work market, division of relatives, compensation and work environment infringement, and absence of a proficient government base that

In this paper, I write about the different potential methods that might be used to approach the undocumented immigration problem in the United States. There are many stances and opinions regarding undocumented immigrants, and there is no “one size fits all” solution to tackle such a massive issue. Therefore, I’ve gathered many different sources to get a broad view of the immigration debate and many different potential solutions that would help to deal with this issue.

The topic of immigration has been argued as a problem to the United States; from the early years the country had first been established. Much reform, and action has been taking to either reduce the amount of illegal immigrants into the country, and even control the usefulness of those who migrate into the in order to benefit the country. Many have found this to be a social problem because of how illegal aliens have allegedly taken jobs away from those who live in the recipient country, or how they are not citizens but are practicing rights of the citizen. Again though much has taken place in effort to relinquish the US of its illegal migrants, but success has yet to be reached completely.

Illegal immigration is a major problem which most of the developed countries face in the current economy, and it has been major political problem for the political parties in America (republicans and democrats) and over years each party has a different agenda to discuss the problem. Illegal immigration can be defined as a movement of people from a source country to the destination country without any legal documents and violates destination countries immigration laws. People have moved across lands over years to escape a war situation or to get better facilities in a different country. Countries have defined immigration laws to restrict people to enter their land without proper documentation as illegal immigration social and time

Ben Franklin once said, “Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.” The main question is, what’s more important, our liberties or our safety? Although security is a major necessity for our country, is it worth losing our human rights? Keeping our liberties is more crucial and has a slightly greater significance than increasing security.

Chapter 14 on page 298 stated During times of war, the threat of war, or terrorism, the public is most concerned about national security. And when crime rates are high or increasing, worries About public safety make crime a high priority issue. People everywhere expect