The Separation Of The Two Stances Lie

Good Essays

Moreover, the opposition of PAS are easily able to argue their stance by the referring to the common ideal that killing is wrong. Nevertheless, where the separation of the two stances lie is that people who are against PAS tend to believe that under any circumstances the killing of another person is unethical. This, in fact, is the view of religious institutions which are the predominant advocate group against the right to die. Nearly all religiously affiliated organizations are fundamentally opposed to PAS. The largest of which being the Roman Catholic Church, one of the biggest global denominations. The NSW Council of Churches explains the religious opposition, clarifying, “Christian teaching affirms the value of each individual, …show more content…

Contradictory to the previous views, the argument for PAS is not as religiously backed, but more focused on personal freedoms and the unnecessary pain that accompanies dying. L.W. Sumner is a Professor Emeritus of Law and Philosophy at the University of Toronto who believes that the outlook on death is changing and driving the movement towards new end-of-life alternatives. As Sumner explains, “there used to be a kind of rhetoric about suffering that had a religious basis-that suffering can be noble, and that [there is] something almost cowardly about trying to avoid or prevent it... That has pretty much eroded away, and people now just tend to see suffering as needless. We used to see death as the enemy. Now we’ve come to see suffering as the enemy”. Sumner believes that once that mindset of unwanted suffering is reached, one will begin to plan to control it, and that control should be provided to every patient. Another key point in the argument of those in favor of PAS is that only the patient can determine the true value of their life. Dr. Ellen Wiebe is quoted asserting that “the experience of suffering is subjective. It’s not up to anyone else to decide how much somebody is suffering. It is only the person themselves who can decide that” (Gulli). Research analyst, Don Ardell agrees with Wiebe. In his report, Ardell asks,“’s most persistent

Get Access