preview

`` The Signalman `` : The Old Nurse 's Story, Saki 's The Open Window, And George

Better Essays

Charles Dickens’s “The Signalman”, Elizabeth Gaskell’s “The Old Nurse’s Story”, Saki’s “The Open Window” and George Elliot’s “The Lifted Veil” all implement the supernatural to either impose a philosophical dilemma, a moral, or poke fun at the Victorian era’s fascination with the supernatural; furthermore, all of the authors utilize their spirits or spiritual gifts to represent various illnesses that manifest in their characters.
“The Signalman” utilizes the trolley problem (a thought experiment meant to test decision making via two impossible choices) through a disturbed train operator (TO). He swears on his life that he sees a spirit in the crimson light that illuminates the tracks whenever trouble begins to brew. As a result he is …show more content…

All of the troubles compiled together can lead up to what is a potential suicide in the story. The reason being that the conductor who ran TO over said he screamed for TO to get out of the way; however, the train still hit TO as he had his back turned.
Elizabeth Gaskell’s “The Old Nurse’s Story” establishes a moral to her story through the ending that is implemented by the ghosts, “‘Yes! she was carried to her bed that night never to rise again. She lay with her face to the wall, muttering low, but muttering always: "Alas! alas! what is done in youth can never be undone in age! What is done in youth can never be undone in age!’”, (Gaskell). The reason her character, Miss Furnivall, is particularly interesting to the piece is because she is deaf; therefore, she cannot hear any of the goings on in the home. However, she can hear everything at the end as she is taken away. The moral being you reap what you sow is heavily implied as Miss Furnivall essentially endures her own form of Hell as she is presumably doomed to suffer under the ghosts of her past. Gaskell uses Miss Furnivall’s suffering (considering her reaction upon realizing the reasons for the hysteria in the home) to establish the supernatural as representations of mental illness. Miss Furnivall in “The Old Nurse’s Story” is a vile woman who, through a combination of jealousy and deceit, manipulates her family into ostracizing the sister; as a

Get Access