1
KirtmanNPSY800-3
NORTHCENTRAL UNIVERSITY
ASSIGNMENT COVER SHEET
Student: Nisaa Kirtman
PSY8100 CLIFFORD
THEORIES OF PERSONALITY 3 (DEBATE EXISTENCE OF THE UNCONSCIOUS)
Faculty Use Only
Debate on Psychoanalysis vs. Behaviorism: Freud and Skinner
Moderator: Good evening, and welcome to the Northcentral University?s debate on psychanalysis versus behaviorism. My name is Nisaa Kirtman and I am from the Department of Psychology. It?s an honor to be the moderator of tonight?s debate. The topic for tonight?s debate are the contrasts between the foundations of psychoanalytic theory, developed by Sigmund Freud, and behavioristic theory, developed by B.F. Skinner.
…show more content…
This is a wrong approach. We must recognize that through therapy, we must bring the unconscious into the conscious mind. Treatment includes talking about our childhood, talking about our urges, and relive these feelings and emotions related to repressed experiences.
Moderator: Dr. Skinner, same question.
Skinner: My position is that the treatment of addiction begins with the theory of reinforcement. Addicts must understand the importance of our environment, and that what we do has consequences from our previous actions (Skinner, 1945). If an individual experiences a negative consequence, there is a high chance that he or she will not repeat that behavior. If the consequences are positive, there is a high chance that the behavior will be repeated (James and Tunney, 2017). An addict must be conditioned, and he or she must re-learn behaviors.
Moderator: Please give us a real-life example of happens with addicts psychologically and environmentally, and use your position to support this example.
Freud: The personality consists of the id, the ego, and the super-ego. The id represents our impulses, and this is the unconscious part of our psyche. On the other hand, the ego is not as chaotic. The ego is more reality-driven, and may take into account etiquette and norms (Sletvold, 2013). Lastly, the super-ego?s aim is to help control and modify the impulses of the id, and
Social psychology and personality psychology both came into fruition around the same time – the 1920’s and 1930’s. Needless
Burton, western & Kowaslki (2015) describes Personality as the enduring patterns of thought, feeling, motivation and behaviour that are expressed in different circumstances. In other words it can be defined as differences in characteristics in a person, including their way of thinking, likes, dislikes, sociability, openness, feelings and behaviour, which make them the person they are and differentiates them from others. All these traits when brought together is known to be the personality of that particular person.
The ego is the mediator between the id and the circumstances of the external world to aid their interaction. The ego represents reason in contrast to the id. Freud called the ego ich, which translates to English as “I”. The ego follows the reality principal. The ego does not exist independently of the id. The ego exists to help the id, and is constantly striving to bring about satisfaction of the id’s instincts. If the ego fails to keep a balance with the id and superego, a person may have difficulty
Freud strategized that the personality was composed of three elements; the id, ego, and superego. The id is the component of personality that is present from birth, and is exclusively unconscious. “According to Freud, the id is the source of all psychic energy, making it the primary component of personality” (Cherry,1). On the other hand, the ego is the element of the personality that is responsible with reality. “According to Freud, the ego develops from the id and ensures that the impulses of the id can be expressed in a manner acceptable in the real world” (Cherry, 1). It
In psychology, there are four major theories of personality: psychodynamic, trait or five-factor model, humanistic, and social-cognitive. The psychodynamic theory primarily focuses on the role of the unconscious mind. The social cognitive theory focuses on the effect of the environment on behavior and is based on theories of learning. Whereas, the humanistic theory emphasizes conscious life experiences and choices. The trait or five-factor model focuses on characteristics themselves and not the roots of personality.
In Freud 's theory, the ego mediates among the id, the super-ego and the external world. Its task is to find a balance between primitive drives, morals, and reality while satisfying the id and superego. Its main concern is with the individual 's safety and allows some of the id
Dr. May then goes into a much more in-depth look at the psychological factors of addiction. The text furthers the discussion of self-deception and goes into specific defense mechanisms that we use when we struggle with an addiction. During this portion of the text it elaborates on the understanding of how we will denial to others and more importantly to ourselves that we are increasing the particular behavior that we are addicted to. The book also mentions how we attempt to rationalize the situation to help us continue our addictive behavior. The text then goes into detail about hiding and delaying tactics, such as how we tell ourselves that “we will quit tomorrow.” The book then goes into the understanding of control issues within the addiction, along with how it effects other and how other effect an individual’s addiction. The book then goes into different areas of the psychological factors and discusses the behavioral issues and the understanding of the psychoanalytical aspect of the issue through explaining how addiction uses our unconscious to develop. There is also a
The psychoanalytic theory by Sigmund Freud has always been argued to be one of the most controversial theories in the school of psychology. Critics have questioned how relevant the perspective of Freud is due to the fact that it holds no scientific basis. Sigmund Freud's psychoanalytic theory of personality argues that human behavior is the result of the interactions among three component parts of the mind: the id, ego, and superego. This theory, known as Freud's structural theory of personality, places great emphasis on the role of unconscious psychological
Freud describes id as the unconscious part of oneself that is based purely on instinct and one that needs to be satisfied immediately. The id tends to act impulsively and make irrational and immoral actions. As development occurs, ego is then developed into oneself. Freud describes one’s ego as “that part of the id which has been modified by the direct influence of the external world” (Freud 25). This ego is create to control the id from its irrational thought process.
Allport defines personality as ‘the dynamic organisation within the individual of those psychological systems that determine his unique adjustment to his environment’ (Allport, 1937). An individual’s unique personality traits and attributes are a powerful indicator of how he/she will interact with the work environment. The difference between average and outstanding employees can often be solely personality related. As the employee is the most valuable asset to the company, ‘selecting the right employee during the process is critical’ (Carbery and Cross, 2013, pp. 41-53)
It is important for psychologists to understand the factors of personality to understand cognitive, emotional and behavioural characteristics required when treating clients. Personality is described as a range of characteristic that controls the way a person thinks, feels and acts that deliver coherence and direction in one’s life. A group of theorists once said, “each of us is in a certain respect like all other people, like some other people and like no other person who has lived in the past or will exist in the future” (Kluchohn & Murray, 1953). It has also been established that a person will behave slightly consistently over time in different situations. Additionally, modest stability is established from childhood personality to adult
Leigh Anne Touhy is the fictional representation of the real life Leigh Anne, famed adoptive mother of Michael Oher from the 2009 film The Blind Side. Leigh Anne is a white interior designer, living in the south with her husband and two children. The family is considered to be part of the upper class, and made their money from owning a string of fast food chains. Leigh Anne and her family take in a black homeless boy, Michael, and throughout the film experience a growing love and bond. They eventually adopt Michael and the Leigh Anne becomes a fiercely protective mother. Very little is revealed about her upbringing
“We are influenced by our own internal forces, forces of which we are unaware, have feelings towards, or urges we do not quite understand “(Freidman, 2012, p. 17). This is the struggle that personality psychology tries to understand, how and to what extent the unconscious forces plays a role in human behavior. It is believed that people are responsible for their own actions. There is a continuous struggle with personality psychology and the comprehension of and to what extent unconscious forces play in human behavior. “Meeting of two personalities is like the contact of two chemical substances; if there is any reaction both are transformed” (Carl Jung 1993, p.57). There are various questions that are asked about the issues in personality psychology such as, “How important are social influences on the self, such as parental deprivation or excessive praise? Is the sense of self merely an inconsequential epiphenomenon or secondary perception arising from other forces that really matter? What is the core of who we are? A second core issue with the studies of personality studies is does each person require a unique approach? “Gordon Allport argued that a key aspect of the study of personality must focus on the individual and thus be idiographic” (p.18). To generalize an individual is a complication in itself because the personality of each person is complex in its own way so how can we generalize? Obtaining an answer to that question is still a dilemma. Allport complained
In this class, we have discussed many different opinions and ideas about the theories of personalities. Of these, I have chosen to incorporate ideas from myself, McAdams, Freud, Jung, Adler, and Horney. I believe that there are seven personality types and each is displayed as a personification in a character from the Peanuts cartoons and comics. The personalities are Neuroticism, Openness to Experience and Imagination, Psychoticism, Passive Aggressive Dependency, Histrionicism, Introversion, and Extraversion. These personality types make up the world, and I believe that any single person can actually have several different personalities.
The human Personality is an individual’s distinctive behaviour, thoughts and emotions which work in tandem to create a unique personality. This essay will analyse the operation of personality by examining the three main psychological theories of; Carl Rogers, Sigmund Freud and Hans Eysenck. These theories were initiated to gain an understanding of the ‘mind’ and how particular personality traits come about. Each of these theories are distinguished by three theoretical approaches, which are: Nomothetic; nomothetic approaches argue that personality is the outcome of permanent characteristics displayed consistently, this is measured using experiments or testing. For example, Eysenck is a ‘type’ theorists because he conducts research using a personality questionnaire. Idiographic; Idiographic approaches argue that each individual has a complex/unique personality. Therefore concerning themselves with the whole person rather than individual characteristics. They believe investigating Individuals in personal, in-depth detail will achieve a unique understanding of them, for example, phenomenological theorists like Rogers use clinical case studies. Last is psychodynamic theories; which tends to be an amalgamation of both nomothetic and idiographic approaches. Example being Freud’s psychic apparatus shared amongst all individuals (id, ego and superego), conversely each individual is unique in regards to the life experiences which sequentially shapes their personality. This also ties