preview

Total Communication In Deaf Education

Decent Essays

The debate over whether or not deaf education should put more stress on teaching deaf students sign or speech has been going on for years. Fittingly, the start of the 1970’s seemed to have introduced a middle ground between oralism and manualism called Total Communication. The idea behind Total Communication was to combine all modes of communication, exposing children to “speech, speechreading, auditory training, fingerspelling, and signs” (Schlesinger, 208). Even if successfully practiced, I don’t believe deaf students would end up successfully bilingual and bicultural because the endless number of methods used in Total Communication would never allow the student to fully grasp or become fluent in any one of those modes of communication. One …show more content…

If a deaf students family personally introduces the deaf child to both the hearing world and deaf world, then the child does have a chance at becoming bicultural. However, even if successfully practiced, TC alone does not focus on biculturalism because their effort is spent on making the deaf student become as hearing as possible. With that being said, the deaf student would not automatically fit into the right upper quadrant on the Nash & Nash frame. Anyone with attitudes and behaviors in this section of the frame would consider themselves both a part of the deaf and hearing communities, with an active acculturation frame and a strong normal socialization frame. Marginality in the frame means that the deaf student can manage a life in both worlds. Having an active acculturation frame means putting an emphasis on ASL, which total communication students lack. In my opinion, the child would not fit into the Deaf community because total communication focuses more on teaching English using non-language signing, such as Signed Systems, and only uses ASL as a back up. (Paul & Quigley, Pg. 183) Most Deaf people, who typically use ASL, would not be able to understand the signing used by TC students. With that being said, there would be no opportunity to establish social relationships with Deaf people or involvement in the Deaf community because of the lack of a common communication mode. Without any of these factors, the child would not be bicultural because they’d be placed more in the hearing world than the deaf

Get Access