Course Number: FIN501
Module 1 Case Assignment
Introduction
Upon deciding to go public, a company looks into preparing an initial public offering (IPO). There are two IPOs with which a company can utilize: a traditional IPO or the relatively new Auction-based IPO that was made popular by Google. Avaya is currently planning for IPO. “Avaya is a global leader in business communications systems. The company provides unified communications, contact centers, data solutions and related services directly and through its channel partners to leading businesses and organizations around the world” (Avaya.com, 2011). Avaya’s current plan of an IPO valued at approximately $1 billion (Klassen, 2011) needs to consider whether to go with a
…show more content…
Once this process has finished, the investment bank is paid a percentage of the sale as commission as well as fees for the underwriting process. Due to the discount of the IPO from the estimate of the market value, traditional IPOs normally trade much higher than the initial price (Clinton, 2011). Being a long used and well known process, traditional IPOs allow for more choices of underwriters. Using an investment bank with experience in traditional IPOs allows for the road show to give the high profile investors a greater idea of the value of the company, and since the allocation of shares is done during this process they can avoid over-valuing the company. Nayantara Hensel writes that underwriters who do less than three IPOs a year will average a first day price increase of 10%. On the other hand Hensel also tells us that the average first day price increase for all traditional IPOs is 38%, meaning a loss in the potential capitol for the company. The investment bank underwriting for a traditional IPO normally gets a 7% underwriting fee of the amount earned or more, bringing the potential money lost to 45-50%.
Auction-Based IPO An auction-based IPO uses the Internet to open a company’s IPO stock for purchase to more potential investors. This process allows a company to spend less on their underwrite fees. The company
After SEC approval, the stock distribution begins. On the chosen effective date, the stock offerings are traded for the first time. However, the closing of the transaction occurs several days later, usually eight days. This is when the underwriter deposits the net proceeds from the IPO into the company account. The underwriter now needs to provide after market stabilization, as well as analyst recommendations, and making a market in the stock, which enhances the demand for shares (Ellis, K., et al, 1999).
Strategic Capital Management, LLC is a hedge fund planning to make financial investments in Creative Computers and Ubid. Creative Computers sold approximately 20% of its Internet auction subsidiary, Ubid, to the public at $15 per share. Ubid's stock price closed the first day of trading at $48, giving Ubid a $439 million market capitalization. On dec 9, Creative Computers had a market capitalization of $ 232 million (22.75 * 10,238,703 outstanding shares) whereas Ubid’s market capitalization amounts to $439 million. This indicates that Ubid currently has a greater market value than the parent company. Moreover, the mispricing can be taken advantage of through an arbitrage opportunity. Paradoxically, the parent's stock price
Many venture capitalistic companies did not or financially could not comply with the new regulations and requirements provided for in the act, so they took their companies to the private sector, no longer offering shares on the public exchange (Ecer & Kahlid, 2013). The main disadvantage to companies regarding SOX is Section 404, the internal controls portion of the act. The major complaint- the requirements of section 404 are “new, radical and ill-considered” (Gupta, Weirich, & Turner, 2012). The internal controls section requires companies to report on their internal control structure and procedures for financial reporting through annual audits, which for small companies is very costly. However, in 2010, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act allowed for the permanent exemption of issuers with a market value of less than $75 million from the Section 404 of the SOX negating this disadvantage, at least for these non-accelerated firms. The additional time needed to implement the requirements of SOX caused issues as well, impacting those small firms the hardest. In addition, investors of foreign companies were not happy with the new regulations of SOX and an estimated loss of five to ten percent of market capital occurred (Litvak,
A small business to pay anywhere from $50,000 and $250,000 to prepare and publicize an Initial Public Offering. The most common known direct costs of IPO are multiple, filing fees, legal fees and taxes, there are however some additional costs. "A small business owner should not be surprised if the cost of an IPO claims between 15 and 20 percent of the proceeds of the sale of stock. Some of the major costs include the lead underwriter's commission; out-of-pocket expenses for legal services, accounting services, printing costs, and the personal marketing "road show" by managers; .02 percent filing costs with the SEC; fees for public relations to bolster the company's image; plus ongoing legal, accounting, filing, and mailing expenses."(Answers.com) Even with all these expences it is possible for the additional fees to come up of for the IPO not to take place at all. When sale does take place it is common for underwriters offer IPO shares at a discounted price to ensure an increase in stock price during the period immediately following the offering. This discount allows the transfer of wealth from the initial investors to new investors. Under pricing is the pricing of
regulations, which intend to protect the public from the fraudulent conduct of several large companies, represent a considerable burden for smaller companies. According to Kessel (2011) “they are part of the reason that fewer biotech companies are going public and instead selling out to larger companies as a means to provide exits for investors”. It is clear that the SOX act does not provide any provisions or distinction between the small and large cap billion dollar firms, thus making it difficult for small firm’s the acquire the necessary capital they need to establish the required controls and sustain growth (Reidy, 2006). According to the act, public companies both small and large, should comply with the set rules and regulations, which
They’re a series of steps involved when issuing the initial public offering. The basic procedure in Canada is as follows:
Public companies are listed on the Stock Exchange and their shares are available for the public to invest in.
The book From Alchemy to IPO: the business of Biotechnology (2001) was a wonderful read. Although a little outdated (before the 2008 financial crisis), Cynthia Robbins-Roth was able to capture the thrill of starting the first biotech companies, the struggle to keep the companies afloat during down markets, as well as the elation of success when a company succeeds where others failed. I was astounded that any new company could survive the decade long march to putting their first product on the market, but Robbins-Roth provided direct quotations from the major investors that stuck with the market when most other investors had pulled out. These quotes, by the end of the book, gave me a much better understanding not only of the biotech industry but also the mentality of the major investors in the field. Although the sector is teeming with risky investments, if you educate yourself about the companies and understand the science involved, and be ready for the long-haul it is possible to lower your risk to reasonable levels.
Investment banking dates all the way back to early America, during the Civil War to be exact. During the Civil War, Jay Cooke, a Philadelphia financier, established the first modern investment bank. Although this was the first “official” investment bank, there had been many private banks doing the same jobs. After the civil war these financial services evolved dramatically. Investment bankers started to influence client companies by sitting on finance committees or even on the board of directors for the companies themselves.
One of the first decisions that Avaya needs to take into consideration is who is likely to buy the IPO. The traditional IPO path holds that a broker will put together a syndicate of brokerage houses that will each take a piece of the IPO (Kamlet & Rini, 1995). They will then portion out the shares they receive to their customers, usually with priority going to the largest and best customers. Avaya, whose true value may actually be much higher than a $1 billion valuation (Klassen, 2011), should be a popular offering if investors can be convinced that the valuation on the IPO is significantly lower than the
Colonel Lilly founded Eli Lily and Company in 1876, because he felt there was a lack of high quality medicine on the market at the time. He also felt the most medicines on the market were ineffective in the curing of ills. In the case “Review Corporate Venture Capital at Eli Lilly and Company”, describes the issues surrounding Eli Lily and Company venture capital arm by showing the struggles the company went through in establishing a corporate venture capital fund. It takes you through the choices that were made keeping in mind the benefits to Eli Lilly and Company as well as keeping the Venture Capital arm separated from the company. This allowed Eli Lilly and Company to benefit from its investments, and kept the
(Q1) Janet Richards and Gilbert Baker own a small firm named InterCat. The firm specializes in the creation and maintenance of Internet catalogues aimed at small businesses. It currently employs around 50 people, most of whom are computer programmers and analysts that follow the high technology market closely. As partners of the firm, they have decided to continue growing and to capture new business from its competitors. To do so, they have decided to start the process of making an initial public offering (IPO). The goal is to start this process as quickly as possible for several reasons, including becoming first to market to capture most of the market share, obtaining a good stock price, and to be one of the few private firms in the
The raw data from the London Stock Exchange was first filtered to only include IPO’s from 2005 onwards, on the main market, listed as “IPO” with “placing” issue type; to get to this original figure of 201 IPOs. These were then filtered further to remain consistent with the previous literature, we remove all foreign listings and those with an initial offering price below £1.
This way they could tell if shareholder wealth would be created. There is a risk due to the cost of equity since it is more complex and is assumed to be the amount that an investor could earn. My advice to Elaine would not change due to the fact that the patent is needed and could create something good for the pharmaceutical industry. She should explain that there was a difference in the ROI but costs are necessary in creating the patent.
Other guarantees would eventually buffet Enron. In the case of Braveheart, CIBC World Markets made a $115.2 million investment in return for a promise of nearly all of Enron's profit from the venture for 10 years. What's more, Enron agreed to repay CIBC its investment, if Braveheart failed to make money.