preview

What's So Funny About America Analysis

Decent Essays

Mills, Brett. The Sitcom. Edinburgh: Edinburgh UP, 2009. Print.

Mill’s piece provides an indepth look at the “Sitcom” and it’s place in genre and vice versa. The piece includes a brief history of the sitcom, the ways in which they are distinguished, and the hybridity of sitcoms as a genre. Mill shows us that because sitcoms have been assumed to be so clearly defined, little to no research has been done on them, when in fact there is very little agreed upon amongst researchers, producers, and viewers alike. Mills concludes that what makes a sitcom is that it has “foregrounds of comedic intent.” Mills piece is thorough, but the back and forth of using genre and sitcom to analyze one another creates confusion. At times, it makes the piece seem unorganized and …show more content…

Comic Visions: Television Comedy and American Culture. Boston: Unwin
Hyman, 1989. Print.

This piece analyzes the sitcom in comparison to stand-up comedy. In the chapter “What’s So Funny About America?” sitcoms are broken down into elements that contrast those of stand-up. Marc describes the two forms of comedy as very different. He states that sitcoms depend on “familiarity, identification, and redemption of popular beliefs” while stand-up normally relies on “the shocking violation of normative taboos.”
Instead of defining sitcom as what it is, this piece draws heavily on what it is compared to stand-up comedy. I agree with this piece that the two are very different, therefore I believe the best way to analyze the two isn’t in comparing or contrasting them. This piece relies too much on stand-up comedy and treats sitcom as the inferior of the two.
The piece first notes that comedy forces people to forget that what they are seeing is fake, but in that exchange experience pure emotion free from guilt. This quote, and the information about sitcoms reinforcing a status quo help to form a realization of why they work and have continued to be a main part of television throughout it’s

Get Access