preview

When Is Lying Justified

Decent Essays

Ever thought about when it is justified for one to lie? Lying is an untruthful statement that someone says to another person. Lying can be used in many scenarios including good and bad. Lying is only sometimes justified such as when it used to protect others’ feelings and to protect others from harm: however some argue that lying will never be justified.
One of the ways in which one can justify lying is when one is lying to protect others’ feelings. For example an article from NBC News supports this by stating, “Your fictional spouse, about to accept a Nobel prize, asks if they look fat. ‘If You’re on the way to the award ceremony, you say, ‘You look fabulous,’ Cohen instructs”. This demonstrates that lying is justified to protect others’ feelings, because if one were to say anything else that would be quite rude and make the person feel bad about it. Although, the other person may want to know the truth and if they are not already on the way to the ceremony, then it would be a …show more content…

An example of this comes from the thoughts of Immanuel Kant where he said, “‘Truthfulness in statements which cannot be avoided is the formal duty of an individual to everyone, however great may be the disadvantage.’” This shows how others believe lying will never believe in lying because they say that telling the truth is a duty in which must always be carried out. It also establishes how telling the truth can be a disadvantage because telling the truth could get one into a situation in which they can not get out of. A final point is said by Blanton when he says, “Being honest all the time is what’s radical and rare.” This shows how others believe people still do not always tell the truth because they withhold information. This also supports how others believe that we should be honest all the time because it is just the right thing to do. Others believe that lying is to never be justified no matter the

Get Access