preview

Workplace Violations

Decent Essays

Based on the facts that are presented in this case study it is clear that a company violation did occur when this IT employee accesses a child pornography site. These violations are violations of the company as well as the federal laws that cover child pornography. In this case study the FBI has been contacted and they are in full control of this situation where they have captured the copies of the computer hard drives utilized and they are proceeding with prosecution activities. The other aspect of this case that has a smell of impropriety is that these company officials entered the office without the employee being there to witness the event. To cap the problem here it is clear that the FBI would not allow a company to copy the hard drive …show more content…

So as companies evolve into the tech savvy world that utilizes both the intranet, and the internet they can continue to see greater and greater misuse among their workforce. To this end it is necessary for companies to develop stricter compliance models that prompts users when unauthorized access is tried while at work. Furthermore in this case study the author has also revealed that this IT employee has also argued that his rights were violated when the company entered his prior office. The text quoted this as “After the employee was arrested and charged with crimes, he argued that the FBI had violated his constitutional rights by searching his computer without a warrant” (Walsh, 2013, p.619). To explore this very valid point it is clear in the case study that it was not the FBI that searched the computer the company had made a copy of the hard drive outside of the site or proximity of the FBI. Also it is clear that the FBI has taken the word of the company officials by accepting the copy as evidence. The fact still remains that the FBI at any time cane seize the computer and verify the existence of the child pornography sites visited to validate the copies content for prosecution. As for whether or not the FBI violated the IT employee’s constitutional rights they had not because they didn’t invade his office or investigate the hard drive of the computer. These pieces of evidence were provided willingly by the IT employee’s employer to the FBI for consideration of prosecution of the law. So to answer the case study question whether or not there had been a violation of the reasonable expectation of privacy on the IT employee’s computer? The answer is no, the computer is the property of the company and

Get Access