Upon reading the stories, I noticed that they all have many similarities and differences. Uncle Nathan is similar to the narrators of “A Secret Lost in the Water” and “To Everything There is a Season” because they are unable to let go of the past. He continues to lament whether the choice he made of saving Delia instead of Eunice was right as he says “I wonder if I would have felt any better about it if I’d got Eunice instead of Delia” (Summers 200). Another thing he has in common with the other
When his father called him to the bushes. Rising Actions: The father shows his son how to find water using an alder branch. The son never really thought about the lesson. He then moves on with his life by getting married, having children and travelling. Climax: The climax is when it the story says “T he alder stayed motionless in my hands and the water beneath the earth refused to sing.” Because we knew he lost the gift at that point. Conclusion: When the narrator tried to put their father’s teaching in action
“A Secret Lost in the Water” is a short story by Roch Carrier. It is a story about how young millennials are forgetting their traditional way of life and are moving into the modern era. The story takes place in a small village where everyone knows one another. “A Secret Lost in the Water” is a story about a father tries to teach his son an important skill of how to find water with an elder branch, but the son does not value it and loses the skill. The main theme in “A Secret Lost in the Water” by
I relate to the struggles of raising a son, like the father in A Secret Lost in the Water. I can vividly remember the moment when my child was born as I knew that my world completely changed. I stared into his innocent eyes and knew that I had possessed a responsibility greater than I ever had before. Truthfully, I never had strong urges either way on the decision of becoming a father. However, after the two rough days in the hospital, our bond grew exponentially. Every day, I strive to impart all
believed that this generational gap exists because the knowledge that fathers might try to endow upon their children is considered “outdated” since the education methods at school become more advanced after each year. Likewise, in the story “A Secret Lost in The Water” by Roch Carrier, the narrator is more captivated by spelling and reading than his father’s stories, since the father and the narrator received different forms of education. For instance, the narrator’s father “was convinced” that his son
what is happening but also gains a message from it. Chronological order is part of the plot diagram in any story where the story begins which takes the reader to rising action. The author of Elephant, Slawomir Mrozek and the author of The Secret Lost in the Water, Roch Carrier showed how chronology is very important to the story. These authors used different themes to portray chronology. This can be demonstrated through the loss of faith, psychology of believing and through appearance vs reality.
“A Secret Lost in the Water”is a short story by Roch Carrier. It is a story about how young Millennials are forgetting their traditional way of life and are moving into the modern era . The story takes place in a small Village where everyone knows one another. “A Secret Lost in the Water” is a story about a father tries to teach his son an important skill of how to find water with an elder branch, but the son does not value it and loses the skill. The main theme in “A Secret Lost in the Water” by
Synthesis Essay Emma The short story “A Secret Lost in the Water” by Roch Carrier and the poem “My Father Is a Simple Man” by Luis Omar Salinas both explores the relationship between their fathers and examines the theme of the differences between generations. “A Secret Lost in the Water” examines more about the narrator’s regret to losing the traditional skills and knowledge in the modern society. Conversely, the poem “My Father Is a Simple Man” explores
literature and art, allowing for nuanced communication and interpretation. Used to grow the story's depth, symbols allow readers to decipher the story through personal perspective. The two short stories, "The Boat" by Alistair Macleod and "A Secret Lost in the Water," by Roch Carrier, both use symbolism in a way that elevates the motifs presented throughout their narrative. Being that a legacy is changed by an individual's choices for their own future, these choices can be directly influenced by recurring
A Secret Lost in the Water - Archetypal Lens The estranged relationships between father and son tend to start from lack of communication. Fathers express their love through actions rather than words. When conflicts occur, they are unlikely to explain themselves, which leads to greater complications. In addition, fathers are often absent in the child’s youth for reasons such as work. However, absent fathers can have great influence on the child.