preview

“[A]T Common Law, There Is No Contribution Among Joint

Decent Essays

“[A]t common law, there is no contribution among joint tort feasors, but that right is now given by statute.” Norfolk & P.B.L.R. Co. v. Parker, 152 Va. 484, 505 (1929). Currently, under Va. Code Ann. § 8.01-34, “[c]ontribution among wrongdoers may be enforced when the wrong results from negligence and involves no moral turpitude.” (emphases added). “The aforementioned code section gives a right of contribution only where the party damaged has a right of action against two or more parties for the same indivisible damage. In short, if the damaged party has a cause of action against only one of the parties responsible for the damage, that one cannot enforce contribution from the other.” Am. Tobacco Co. v. Transport Corp., 277 F. Supp. 457, …show more content…

Exchange v. Truck Ins. Exchange, 310 F.2d 653, 658 (1962). In Carriers Ins. Exchange, the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals held that contribution is unavailable to parties who intentionally violated a statute and safety regulations where a defendant was transporting petroleum without a required permit. Id. In that case, the Fourth Circuit relied on the Restatement of Restitution for the proposition that
It is generally held that a person who has violated the law should not be permitted to invoke it to obtain restitution in reference to the same transaction, especially when the law in question has been set up for the protection of the public and the denial of restitution will tend to prevent further misconduct. On the other hand contribution is generally allowed when the claimant 's conduct amounted to mere negligence or mistake without intentional violation of the law.

Id. at 658 (quoting Restatement of Restitution, §§ 86, 88). Comment c. to § 88 of the Restatement provides:
Public policy prevents restitution in favor of a person who, whether or not by agreement with or at the request of another, has committed a seriously wrongful act. It is a matter for judicial discretion to determine whether an act is so seriously wrongful as to bar restitution under the particular circumstances. Normally consciously criminal conduct

Get Access