Coleman Priscilla K. et al. ‘‘Induced abortion and anxiety, mood, and substance abuse disorders, Isolating’’. Journal of Psychiatric Research (2008), doi:10.1016/j.jpsychires.2008.10.009
The particular article is against abortion and tries to link abortion and some of the disorders including various anxieties like panic attacks, panic disorder, agoraphobia and PTSD. The article also links abortion to mood disorders like bipolar, major depression and mania. On the other hand, the article is important for review because it suggests that abortion can be linked to substance abuse disorders like alcohol and drug abuse as well as dependence. Using national survey reports, the article suggests that evidence confirm the relationship between abortion
…show more content…
The entire article is devoted to evaluation the existing relationship between induced abortion and the mental health of the women. In essence, the article addresses two issues; the risks of abortion in comparison to the risks of considering the alternatives and sources of the different response from the women after abortion. In return, the article seeks to reflect the American Psychology Association Task Force on Mental Health and Abortion of 2008. The article reflects on these empirical evidences and suggests that they are not accurate and do not explore the real courses behind mental health and abortion. Therefore, it is an important source to review because it suggests that the mental health risks among women who have legal, single and first-trimester abortion of the unwanted pregnancies is less greater or intense that those of the women who deliver the unwanted pregnancies. In this case, the article reports that there is no evidence linking abortion to mental health problems and that most of the women who terminate their pregnancies barely experience mental problems but some to experience implying that the mental health problem is associated with pre-existing conditions of the abortion. In this case, the information presented in the article suggests the importance of understanding the varied abortion experiences …show more content…
The authors argue that stigmatization discredits the individuals who associate themselves with abortion. The importance of this article stems from the fact that the topic, abortion stigmatization has never received much attention and as such, has been under-researched as well as under-theorized and that the few studies that exist focus on the women who have engaged in abortion. In this regard, the article describes the groups facing abortion stigma including the women who abort, the people working for the facilities providing abortion services and proponents of the women who abort including family, partners, friends including the advocates and researchers of abortion. The article goes further to discuss the various reasons for abortion stigma including legal restrictions, the notion that abortion is unhealthy and dirty, use of stigma for the anti-abortion efforts and that abortion violates a woman ideals of motherhood and sexuality. Therefore, the article is a good choose since it explains that a better understanding of the abortion stigma will help in establishing strategies for reducing the problem and this has positive implications for the accessibility to better healthcare for the women who have been
Various studies have been conducted to show the psychological effects following an abortion. According to the results some women experience depression and anxiety. These psychological effects reflect on several factors. Abortion may relieve stress by ending an unwanted pregnancy, but the event itself may simultaneously be experienced as a stressor causing anxiety grief, guilt, despair and anger. These factors could lead to depression, as feelings of powerless, anger and self-condemnation are emotions that underlie depression. Controversies exist whether abortion is linked with mental health or not. Future research requires a better understanding of the conditions that lead to unwanted pregnancy and abortion with the ultimate goal of improving women’s lives and well being.
One of the most widely discussed issues within the topic of abortion is the mental health of the mother. Research by Guttmacher Advisory says “Based on the best scientific evidence currently available, there is no credible evidence that abortion, in and of itself, causes mental health problems for most women.”(2008). Guttmacher backs their claims with studies and research done by the American Psychological Association (APA). The APA states that many studies didn’t take into account how a woman’s mental health was before thinking about abortion. They also point out that any significant life event is stressful such as divorce or a death so one cannot say abortion
In the overarching state of humanity, few topics are as important to the long term societal standpoint as abortion. Even more important and contested is the controversial subject of whether or not a woman will endure long term psychological effects or disorders after said abortion. This subject has been highly debated, with valid points made by both sides. It is important that we all look into these repercussions, especially since approximately 33% of women will undergo an abortion by the time they reach forty-five years old. This often challenged subject has many aspects. The main ideas that I researched where whether or not having an abortion leads to a higher risk for mental health issues, whether or not “post-abortion syndrome” is a
Cohen, Susan A. "Abortion and mental health: myths and realities."Guttmacher Policy Review 9.3 (2006): 8-16. Web 27 Jan. 2016.
Abortion can cause periods of depression in which the pain can encysted. Some women become aggressive or nervous, or even hyperactive. Anxiety can find an answer food such as bulimia or, conversely, anorexia. For others, psychosomatic reactions will take over with stomach aches, absence of periods, headaches, the loss of self-esteem ("I'm bad, I'm unworthy, painful for others"), the fear of not being pregnant again or anxiety of existential insecurity are consequences commonly observed. Some episodes of a woman’s life can relive the acutely suffering felt at the time of abortion: the date in which the child had been born, or the anniversary date of the abortion, the desire to make present the dead child, are conducive to outbreaks of suffering intensely lived as, for example, anxiety or depressive
Earlier studies of Curley and Johnston’s experiment were taken place to study women in college, who took initiative for psychological treatment after the experience of an abortion. That previous study discovered the variety of behaviors and actions that would decrease psychological distress for young women exposed to termination of their child birth. The college women were given the choice of which they would prefer to proceed towards after an abortion. In conclusion, the study also recognized that women can experience a strong condition of chronic and post-traumatic stress, if sought psychological treatment. Curley and Johnston’s journal discusses the data taken from 151 female participants classified into three experimental groups: women
Abortion is a controversial topic in today’s society in more ways than one. Part of the controversy results in a stigma regarding abortion regarding its impact on the woman who underwent the abortion procedure. Researchers Charles et al. and Henry David conducted studies regarding the effects of abortion on the mother and the effects on the child if they were denied abortion, respectively. The findings of the studies explored the psychological effects on women who were granted an abortion and the children of those who were denied an abortion throughout life.
Nearly 81% of women who receive abortions experience subsequent mental health problems according to a recently published study by The Royal College of Psychiatrists. The study demonstrates that the aftermath of an abortion can result in higher rates of anxiety, depression, various forms of substance abuse, and suicidal behavior. As a result of the study, it shows that women who have an abortion face almost double the risk of mental health problems as women who have their baby. This outcome is due to the fact that most women who are terminating pregnancies “may feel a greater sense of loss, anxiety and distress due to lack of support”, as summarized in the Guttmacher Institute, a non-profit reproductive health organization. In fact, a five-year study shows that 25% of
Abortion is a topic that when spoken about gives many individuals a sense of uncomfortableness and many tend to shy away from this topic; Because abortion is a topic which has sparked many debates on whether it is acceptable or not. Societies have developed different stigmas around abortion and it affects many woman and how they live there life. This topic is relevant to my generation as the stigma of abortion is still very prevalent. To properly look at this issue, one must look into many different aspects of the abortion argument. By narrowing down the research, I came to the conclusion of 4 major aspects that shape the stigma around abortion. The historical roles of a woman play a major role in the social construct of abortion. If historically a woman is meant to be a mother and a nurturer; how does abortion pertain to that idea and how can it effectively be justified? Additionally, the stigmatism around abortion currently and the main ideas of motherhood give abortion a tainted view for the individuals that are undergoing this operation or are in a situation to make that decision. If one is to be pushed away for her decision as well as affecting the individuals around her, what does that have to say about the already heavily stigmatised topic? As well, when looking into a topic, one must realize that traditions, norms, values and ideas come from years before and that the older generation plays a huge role in this. If the older generation was raised, and is raising
This journal address the relationship on abortions and how women are mentally affected by it. It address two issues, one the risk that occurs with abortion as opposed to the risk that its alternative brings up, and two how a women responds after she have the abortion. An important point that was stated in the journal was that women who have a first-trimester abortion of a pregnancy that they do not want is not greater than women who choose not to have an abortion and deliver the unwanted baby. I am going to use this journal in my research to help me further discuss how abortion affects the aborter. It will help me give credibility to the research that I am trying to prove on how many women have different affects and the reason why they may
Today, abortion has become another political issue, rather than the intimate choice of a woman. Abortion isn’t a new issue because in the case, Roe vs. Wade, the court’s decision was the first step, where women could do as they wish with their body in a safe, legal manner. So why, after forty-one years since this case was passed is abortion an issue again? Abortion is often presented as if it is new and people have just started doing it years ago, when in reality the practice of abortion has dated back to ancient times. Abortion is the trending topic once again because “The Affordable Care Act”, also known as ‘Obama care’, has made abortion an issue with its new expansion of abortion coverage. This paper will examine all of the harmful ways abortions can harm your body and also how they may affect you in a positive and in a negative way. Also, it helps you understand why people decide to get an abortion and the government has made abortion such a popular topic. Even though you may not agree with the decision of abortion, you have to have an open mind to other people’s decisions and opinions towards them.
The practice of abortions throughout the United States are safe. Abortions have become safer since the procedure was reluctantly legalized in the United States-by the Supreme Court-in 1973. According to The American Medical Association’s Council on Scientific Affairs the number of deaths associated with abortion drastically dropped from roughly four out of every one hundred thousand women in 1973 to .6 per every one hundred thousand women in 1997 (Abortion is Safe). These statistics show that procedure in how an abortion is performed has become safer since legalization. Legalization of abortion permitted the procedure to be performed in a sterile setting- such as a hospital operating room. The medical risk associated with an abortion procedure is highly overestimated. An abortion performed exactly as medically advised carries half the risk of a tonsillectomy (Abortion is Safe). (A tonsillectomy is a simple procedure that is performed on many children in their childhood.) On the other hand, anti-abortion advocates point to emotional problems that could harm the pregnant woman after an abortion. These advocates attempt to show there is a link to mental disorders in post abortion women. A New Zealand study looked to verify this claim. The analysis showed that there was a credible link between depression, suicide attempts and substance abuse in post abortion women (Cords). Researchers also aimed to connect having an abortion with post-traumatic stress disorder
Although abortion gives women that sense of gender equality and the right to their own body, it should not make one have to suffer through the dreading aftermath of destruction. When one is considering having an abortion for having a better life, one should consider that abortion is not a safety net but a safety hazard, it just depends the way one handles the situation. On the whole, responding to suffer more psychological side effects than physical or social. It seems reasonable that due to advances in medical technology and education, physical consequences of abortion decrease. Nevertheless, psychological consequences of abortion which refer mainly to very personal understanding and feelings of abortion practiced by individuals may be rooted
There are religious and emotional objections to abortion as well as the possibility of negative medical and mental consequences. Many are in favor of making abortion illegal because, they feel it is immoral. Others believe that government should not have a say so in such a personal matter. Are there any other factors that could possibly change the way people view abortion? The matter of abortions negatively affecting the women who have the procedure done is one that the world has been dealing with for some time now. Researchers have decided to explore the idea that women who have had an abortion could possibly be at a higher risk for developing and even intensifying mental health issues. Researchers use various measures to determine if or how having an abortion effects woman. Measures include factors such as women who request an abortion but have not yet gone through with it, women who have gone through with the procedure, and women who have lost a child due to abortions or other ways. The following literature explains these
Although all four of these causes stress remains the most prominently associated cause, meaning that it is also linked to the other three possible causes. In order to specify the primary cause of spontaneous abortion, a study should be performed that studies only the effects of stress, depression, antidepressant usage, and alcohol consumption. In this study women should be both medically examined throughout their pregnancy and asked questions about their mental state and well being. Researchers should analyze the pregnancies of 200 women, 50 of which will be used as a control. The remaining 150 expecting women should be separated into three categories, women who are depressed and are not using antidepressants, women who are both depressed and exposed to antidepressants, and women who are consuming alcohol during their pregnancy. Women in each category should be asked a set of previously established questions regarding their stress levels and possible causers of the recorded stress. Additionally, women within the three non-control groups should be asked predetermined questions about how their depression or alcohol consumption relate to the amount of stress they record. This study should as a whole determine if stress is the primary cause of spontaneous