preview

Addiction: The Medical Model

Decent Essays

Medical Model

According to the medical model, addiction is a progressive disease that needs to be treated at the individual level (Morse, 2004; Nunes-Dinis & Barth, 1993). The medical model states there is a large biological difference between a normal person’s brain and an addict’s brain. In fact, the brains of addicts have been shown to possess common elements of addiction, independent of the kind of substance abused. Consequently, the addicts are not responsible for their cravings of harmful substances. The behaviors exhibited by addicts are only the symptoms of the disease and not the disease itself. Therefore, instead of punishing the addict, nonjudgmental and therapeutic responses are appropriate. Addiction requires intervention …show more content…

The public health perspective seeks to address substance abuse problems at the community level and tries to help as many people as possible at one time in natural environments. Thus, a specific individual’s motivation to change is irrelevant. Because the entire population of high-risk groups is targeted, the intervention is brief and cost effective. However, the rate of change is low. Thus, in the public health perspective, change is a mile wide and an inch deep.

According to the public health perspective, an addict’s inappropriate behaviors are influenced by the environment. Addicts need to identify and prevent inappropriate behaviors before they happen (Blanchard & Tabachnick, 2002). Addicts need to be educated so that their attitudes and beliefs about harmful substances can be changed. In addition, addicts need to remove themselves from harmful environments. Addicts need to move to friendlier environments with family members, peer groups, and others who will have a positive …show more content…

First, there was no control group. Thus, there is no fixed reference in which to compare the test results. Second, researchers dropped subjects from the study who did not have a permanent home address or who had legal problems. Dropping these high risk clients from the study meant the loss of valuable data. Finally, because MATCH researchers had strict screening and recruitment processes, because they performed one-on-one treatment sessions instead of group therapy, and because they performed personalized follow-up sessions, the study’s external validity was

Get Access