preview

Analysis Of Michael Sandel 's Justice

Better Essays

Joshua J. Castro
Professor Iyer
Pol-1
10 October 2014
Episode – 05
An Analysis of Michael Sandel 's Justice Can the value of human life be determined by dollars and cents? Is one life more valuable than another, or can one be tossed aside like the leftover change someone receives after buying a hamburger from McDonald 's? Placing a monetary value on someone 's life is nearly impossible to do, as can be seen in Episode 05 of Michael Sandel 's Justice series. Episode 05 is split into two parts, both involving how to determine if a price can be placed on the life of a fellow human being. Part one discusses whether or not it is acceptable to pay someone else to take one 's place during military conscription, while part two focuses on whether or not paying for a surrogate mother or father is in fact a monetary transaction of human life. The transaction of human life seems to be morally wrong, but at the same time can be justified. Are human lives simply a figure that can be determined by someone who is paid to see how much someone is worth, or how much someone will be worth? Although the life of someone can be objectively valued, a human life should not be monetarily valued for any reason. The first part of this lecture discussed whether or not someone 's draft rights can be sold to another willing to accept payment for their substitution of service. Sandel states the fact that steel titan, Andrew Carnegie, sold his draft rights to another citizen to take his place

Get Access